School of Social Work, 8166University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Centre for Research on Personhood in Dementia, 8166University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Dementia (London). 2022 Oct;21(7):2310-2350. doi: 10.1177/14713012221111014. Epub 2022 Jun 29.
Citizenship has provided an important conceptual framework in dementia research and practice over the past fifteen years. To date, there has been no attempt to synthesize the multiple perspectives that have arisen in this literature. The purpose of this paper is to explore, reflect on, and contrast, the key concepts and trends in the citizenship discourse as it relates to people with dementia. Using a scoping review methodology, forty-nine articles were identified for review. Despite the use of different descriptors, thematic analysis revealed four core themes underpinning citizenship discourse: 1) the relationality of citizenship; 2) facilitated agency and autonomy; 3) attention to stigma, discrimination and exclusion; and 4) recognition of the possibilities of identity and growth. Overall, this scoping review found a major emphasis on expanding definitions of agency and autonomy to render citizenship unconditional and inclusive of the diverse life experiences of people living with dementia. Notably, there is recognition that a more intersectional lens for embedding the subjective experience within a broader socio-political context is needed. Whilst the adoption of a citizenship lens in dementia research and practice has had real-world implications for policy and research, its exploration and use continue to be led by academics, highlighting the importance that future research involve input form people with dementia.
公民身份在过去十五年的痴呆症研究和实践中提供了一个重要的概念框架。迄今为止,尚未有人试图综合这一文献中出现的多种观点。本文旨在探讨、反思和对比与痴呆症患者相关的公民话语中的关键概念和趋势。使用范围综述方法,确定了 49 篇文章进行审查。尽管使用了不同的描述符,但主题分析揭示了公民话语的四个核心主题:1)公民身份的关系性;2)促进代理和自主权;3)关注污名、歧视和排斥;4)承认身份和成长的可能性。总的来说,这项范围综述发现,人们主要强调扩大代理和自主权的定义,以使公民身份无条件地包容和包含痴呆症患者的各种生活经历。值得注意的是,人们认识到需要采用更具交叉性的视角,将主观体验嵌入更广泛的社会政治背景中。虽然在痴呆症研究和实践中采用公民视角对政策和研究产生了实际影响,但它的探索和使用仍然由学者主导,这突显了未来研究需要纳入痴呆症患者的意见的重要性。