Birt Linda, Poland Fiona, Csipke Emese, Charlesworth Georgina
School of Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, UK.
Division of Psychiatry, University College London, UK.
Sociol Health Illn. 2017 Feb;39(2):199-211. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.12530.
Within western cultures, portrayals of dementia as 'a living death' are being challenged by people living with the diagnosis. Yet dementia remains one of the most feared conditions. The sociological lens of citizenship provides a conceptual framework for reviewing the role of society and culture in repositioning dementia away from deficit to a discourse of agency and interdependence. Awareness of cognitive change, and engaging with the diagnostic process, moves people into a transitional, or 'liminal' state of uncertainty. They are no longer able to return to their previous status, but may resist the unwanted status of 'person with dementia'. Drawing on qualitative studies on social participation by people with dementia, we suggest that whether people are able to move beyond the liminal phase depends on acceptance of the diagnosis, social capital, personal and cultural beliefs, the responses of others and comorbidities. Some people publicly embrace a new identity whereas others withdraw, or are withdrawn, from society to live in the shadow of the fourth age. We suggest narratives of deficit fail to reflect the agency people with dementia can enact to shape their social worlds in ways which enable them to establish post-liminal citizen roles. (A Virtual Abstract of this paper can be viewed at: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_979cmCmR9rLrKuD7z0ycA).
在西方文化中,将痴呆症描绘成“行尸走肉”的观点正受到被诊断患有此病的人们的挑战。然而,痴呆症仍然是最令人恐惧的病症之一。公民身份的社会学视角为审视社会和文化在将痴呆症从缺陷话语重新定位为能动性和相互依存话语中所起的作用提供了一个概念框架。对认知变化的认知以及参与诊断过程,会使人们进入一种过渡性的、或“阈限性”的不确定状态。他们不再能够回到以前的状态,但可能会抗拒“痴呆症患者”这种不受欢迎的身份。基于对痴呆症患者社会参与的定性研究,我们认为人们是否能够超越阈限阶段取决于对诊断的接受程度、社会资本、个人和文化信仰、他人的反应以及合并症。一些人公开接受新身份,而另一些人则退出或被社会疏离,生活在老年的阴影中。我们认为,缺陷叙事未能反映痴呆症患者能够以塑造其社会世界的方式来展现能动性,从而使他们能够确立阈限后公民角色。(本文的虚拟摘要可在以下网址查看:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_979cmCmR9rLrKuD7z0ycA)