Anesthesia and Intensive Care Unit, Fatebenefratelli Hospital, Milan, Lombardy, Italy.
Pediatric Anesthesia and Intensive Care Unit, "Vittore Buzzi" Children Hospital, Milan, Lombardy, Italy.
J Vasc Access. 2024 Jan;25(1):313-317. doi: 10.1177/11297298221085424. Epub 2022 Jun 30.
In pediatric patients, PICC insertion is often performed under sedation to reduce pain and anxiety, which is associated with risks such as laryngospasm, apnea, and hypoxia. Furthermore, it requires a pediatric anesthesiologist. The aim of our study was to evaluate the VR as an alternative to pharmacological sedation to reduce those risks and the overall cost.
We tested a VR immersive experience for ten children requiring a PICC. To achieve this, we ran a software, specifically designed for the pediatric healthcare setting, on a commercially available VR headset.In order to evaluate this new practice, we recorded the following data:Patient's anxiety before and after the procedure, recorded through a modified numeric rating scale from 0 (no anxiety) to 10 (worst anxiety imaginable).Patient's pain before (e.g., because of preexisting medical conditions) and after the procedure through a Wong-Baker scale.Caregiver's satisfaction.No active or passive restraint was enforced during the whole procedure, patients had to keep their arms still all by themselves.
Out of the 10 patients only in a single case, we had to interrupt the attempt with the VR technique and let the anesthesiologist perform a sedation. From the immediate beginning said patient had trouble adapting to the virtual environment and tried to remove the headset.In all other cases, we noticed a drop in the anxiety level of the patient and the pain never increased. Globally, caregivers were pleased with the experience and reported an average satisfaction rate of 9.3 out of 10.
Virtual reality seems a valid alternative to traditional sedation in pediatric patients undergoing a PICC placement procedure. Additional studies, with adequate sample size, of patients are necessary to assess the benefit from this new approach, as well as its impact on the overall procedure length.
在儿科患者中,PICC 置管术常需在镇静下进行,以减轻疼痛和焦虑,这会带来诸如喉痉挛、呼吸暂停和缺氧等风险。此外,还需要小儿麻醉师。我们的研究目的是评估虚拟现实(VR)作为替代药物镇静的方法,以降低这些风险和总体成本。
我们对 10 名需要进行 PICC 置管术的儿童进行了 VR 沉浸式体验测试。为此,我们在一款商业 VR 头显上运行了一款专门为儿科医疗环境设计的软件。为了评估这种新方法,我们记录了以下数据:
患者在术前和术后的焦虑程度,通过 0(无焦虑)到 10(可想象的最严重焦虑)的改良数字评分量表进行记录。
患者在术前(例如,由于先前存在的医疗状况)和术后的疼痛,通过 Wong-Baker 量表进行记录。
照顾者的满意度。
整个过程中没有使用主动或被动约束,患者必须自行保持手臂静止。
在 10 名患者中,只有 1 名患者在尝试 VR 技术时不得不中断,并让麻醉师进行镇静。从一开始,该患者就难以适应虚拟环境,并试图取下头盔。在所有其他情况下,我们注意到患者的焦虑水平降低,疼痛从未加重。总体而言,照顾者对体验感到满意,并报告平均满意度为 10 分中的 9.3 分。
虚拟现实似乎是儿科患者接受 PICC 置管术时替代传统镇静的有效方法。需要进一步开展具有足够样本量的研究,以评估这种新方法的益处,以及其对整个手术过程长度的影响。