Centre du Cerveau2, University Hospital of Liège, Liège, Belgium.
Coma Science Group, GIGA-Consciousness, University of Liège, Liège, Belgium.
Semin Neurol. 2022 Jun;42(3):283-298. doi: 10.1055/a-1893-2785. Epub 2022 Jul 6.
The investigation of sleep in disorders of consciousness (DoC) has shown promising diagnostic and prognostic results. However, the methods employed in this field of research are diverse. This leads to confusion in the way forward for both scientific and clinical purposes. We review the literature that has investigated sleep in DoC patients and specifically outline the methodologies used next to the presented results. We highlight what knowledge we currently have and where increased efforts are needed before further clinical implementation. Specifically, the review shows that successful methods may employ a two-stage approach to sleep scoring, where one is the application of loosened standard criteria and the other a more general factor describing closeness of the electroencephalography to a healthy pattern, including a score that describes the extent to which sleep scoring criteria can be applied. This should be performed as part of a multimodal approach that also includes investigations of eye-opening/closure and that of circadian (24-hour) rhythmicity. Taken together, this puts the most promising methodologies in the field together for a comprehensive investigation. Large-scale approaches, incorporating multiple modalities and looking at individual variation, are now needed to advance our understanding of sleep in DoC and its role in diagnosis, treatment, and recovery.
对意识障碍(DoC)患者睡眠的研究已显示出有希望的诊断和预后结果。然而,该领域研究中使用的方法多种多样。这导致在科学和临床目的方面都出现了混乱。我们回顾了研究 DoC 患者睡眠的文献,并特别概述了所使用的方法及其呈现的结果。我们强调了我们目前所拥有的知识,以及在进一步临床实施之前需要更多努力的地方。具体来说,该综述表明,成功的方法可能采用睡眠评分的两阶段方法,其中一个是应用放宽的标准标准,另一个是更一般地描述脑电图与健康模式的接近程度的因素,包括一个描述可以应用睡眠评分标准的程度的分数。这应作为多模态方法的一部分进行,该方法还包括对睁眼/闭眼和 24 小时节律性的研究。总的来说,这将该领域最有前途的方法整合在一起,进行全面的研究。现在需要采用大规模方法,结合多种模式并着眼于个体差异,来提高我们对 DoC 睡眠及其在诊断、治疗和恢复中的作用的理解。