Hsieh L F, Didenko B, Schumacher H R, Torg J S
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1987 May;68(5 Pt 1):294-7.
This study sought to determine if weakness and poor endurance of quadriceps and hamstring muscles are present in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients with minimally involved knees; determine if there is an abnormal hamstring/quadriceps ratio or abnormal torque curves in RA patients; and begin to evaluate the feasibility of isokinetic (IK) exercise in RA patients. Sixteen RA patients with minimally involved knees and 16 matched control subjects were tested bilaterally with a Cybex II dynamometer. Torque values in the RA group were significantly less (78% for isokinetic and 81% for isometric). The hamstring/quadriceps torque ratio was significantly higher in the RA patients than in the controls: 66.8% vs 61.7%. There was no significant difference in endurance between the two groups. In the RA patients the angle at which peak torque occurred shifted later in the range of motion (37.4 degrees) compared with the control subjects (28.7 degrees). Except for IK torque of hamstring muscles in the control group, there was no significant difference in the torque values between the right and left sides in RA patients or control subjects. The findings suggested that even in RA patients with minimally involved joints, muscle weakness was present; exercise of quadriceps should be emphasized since in RA patients quadriceps were weaker than hamstrings; and isokinetic testing is feasible in selected patients with RA.
本研究旨在确定膝关节受累程度最低的类风湿关节炎(RA)患者是否存在股四头肌和腘绳肌无力及耐力差的情况;确定RA患者是否存在异常的腘绳肌/股四头肌比率或异常的扭矩曲线;并开始评估等速(IK)运动在RA患者中的可行性。对16例膝关节受累程度最低的RA患者和16例匹配的对照受试者双侧使用Cybex II测力计进行测试。RA组的扭矩值显著更低(等速测试为78%,等长测试为81%)。RA患者的腘绳肌/股四头肌扭矩比率显著高于对照组:66.8% 对 61.7%。两组之间的耐力无显著差异。与对照受试者(28.7度)相比,RA患者中出现峰值扭矩的角度在运动范围内更靠后(37.4度)。除对照组腘绳肌的IK扭矩外,RA患者或对照受试者左右两侧的扭矩值无显著差异。研究结果表明,即使在关节受累程度最低的RA患者中也存在肌肉无力;应强调股四头肌的锻炼,因为在RA患者中股四头肌比腘绳肌更弱;并且等速测试在选定的RA患者中是可行的。