Department of Physiology, University College of Medical Sciences, University of Delhi, Delhi, India.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2022 Sep 1;46(3):491-497. doi: 10.1152/advan.00041.2022. Epub 2022 Jul 7.
Professionalism and communication were formally introduced in India's Competency-Based Curriculum (CBC) as part of the five roles of an Indian medical graduate and 10 core competencies in the Bachelor of Science Nursing program. It may be challenging to teach the complexity of clinical medical ethics to undergraduate students at a young age in the absence of direct patient interaction. Trigger films (TFs) are brief (3-10 min) clips that have been used in the West to provoke debate, promote reflection, and assist trainees in dealing with ethical dilemmas. The aim of this study was to determine whether TFs can be used to teach professionalism and ethics to undergraduate medical and nursing students as an innovative and interesting tool and to see whether this results in any changes in knowledge. A 2-h module supported by an introductory PowerPoint presentation and using four TFs on the four pillars of ethics (beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy, and justice) was developed and piloted in the foundation course for the new cohort of medical and nursing students. Quantitative, open-ended feedback was taken from learners after module delivery, and knowledge was assessed with a retrospective pre-post questionnaire. The majority of students found TFs an innovative and interesting tool to teach medical ethics. There was a gain in knowledge of autonomy (52%), beneficence (48%), nonmaleficence (46%), and justice (38%). TFs can be effective tools to impart core competencies in ethics and professionalism to both nursing and medical students in the new CBC. Teaching ethics is an important part of the medical curriculum, and since first-year students are not in direct contact with patients it is necessary to think of innovative methods that can be used to teach. We have done the pilot testing for the same, using trigger films among undergraduate medical and nursing students.
专业性和沟通能力被正式引入印度的能力本位课程(CBC),作为印度医学毕业生的五个角色之一,以及理学士护理课程的 10 项核心能力。如果没有与患者的直接互动,在学生还很年轻的时候,教授临床医学伦理学的复杂性可能具有挑战性。触发电影(TFs)是简短的(3-10 分钟)剪辑,已在西方用于引发辩论、促进反思并帮助学员处理道德困境。本研究旨在确定 TFs 是否可以用作向医学生和护理学生教授专业性和伦理学的创新且有趣的工具,以及这是否会导致知识发生任何变化。一个 2 小时的模块,由介绍性的 PowerPoint 演示文稿和四个关于伦理四大支柱(善行、不伤害、自主和公正)的 TFs 提供支持,在新医学和护理学生群体的基础课程中进行了试点。在模块交付后,从学习者那里获得了定量的、开放式的反馈,并且通过回顾性的预-后问卷调查评估了知识。大多数学生认为 TFs 是教授医学伦理学的创新且有趣的工具。在自主(52%)、善行(48%)、不伤害(46%)和公正(38%)方面都有了知识的增益。TFs 可以成为向新 CBC 中的护理和医学生传授伦理学和专业性核心能力的有效工具。教授伦理学是医学课程的重要组成部分,由于一年级学生与患者没有直接接触,因此有必要考虑可以用于教学的创新方法。我们已经在本科医学生和护理学生中对其进行了试点测试,使用了触发电影。