Department of Biology, Misericordia University, Dallas, Pennsylvania, USA.
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Anat. 2022 Aug;241(2):272-296. doi: 10.1111/joa.13679. Epub 2022 Jul 8.
The Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Ruth Mason Dinosaur Quarry (RMDQ) represents a monodominant Edmontosaurus annectens bonebed from the Hell Creek Formation of South Dakota and has been determined as a catastrophic death assemblage likely belonging to a single population, providing an ideal sample to investigate hadrosaurid growth and population dynamics. For this study, size-frequency distributions were constructed from linear measurements of long bones (humeri, femora, tibiae) from RMDQ that revealed five relatively distinct size classes along a generally right-skewed distribution, which is consistent with a catastrophic assemblage. To test the relationship between morphological size ranges and ontogenetic age classes, subsets from each size-frequency peak were transversely thin-sectioned at mid-diaphysis to conduct an ontogenetic age assessment based on growth marks and observations of the bone microstructure. When combining these independent datasets, growth marks aligned with size-frequency peaks, with the exclusion of the overlapping subadult-adult size range, indicating a strong size-age relationship in early ontogeny. A growth curve analysis of tibiae indicated that E. annectens exhibited a similar growth trajectory to the Campanian hadrosaurid Maiasaura, although attaining a much larger asymptotic body size by about 9 years of age, further suggesting that the clade as a whole may have inherited a similar growth strategy. This rich new dataset for E. annectens provides new perspectives on other hypotheses of hadrosaurid life history. When the RMDQ population was compared with size distributions from other hadrosaurid bonebed assemblages, juveniles (categorized as ages one and two) were either completely absent from or heavily underrepresented in the samples, providing support for the hypothesized segregation between juvenile and adult hadrosaurids. Osteohistological comparison with material from polar and temperate populations of Edmontosaurus revealed that previous conclusions correlating osteohistological growth patterns with the strength of environmental stressors were a result of sampling non-overlapping ontogenetic growth stages.
白垩纪晚期(马斯特里赫特阶)的 Ruth Mason 恐龙采石场(RMDQ)代表了南达科他州地狱溪组中的单一埃德蒙顿龙属(Edmontosaurus)骨骼床,已被确定为可能属于单一群体的灾难性死亡组合,为研究鸭嘴龙的生长和种群动态提供了理想的样本。在这项研究中,对 RMDQ 的长骨(肱骨、股骨、胫骨)的线性测量构建了大小频率分布,显示出五个相对明显的大小类群,沿着大致右偏的分布,这与灾难性组合一致。为了测试形态大小范围与个体发育年龄类群之间的关系,从每个大小频率峰值中选取子集,在中轴进行横向薄片切割,根据生长标记和骨微观结构的观察进行个体发育年龄评估。当将这些独立数据集结合起来时,生长标记与大小频率峰值对齐,除了重叠的亚成体-成体大小范围外,这表明在早期个体发育中存在强烈的大小-年龄关系。胫骨的生长曲线分析表明,埃德蒙顿龙属(Edmontosaurus)表现出与坎潘阶鸭嘴龙类(Hadrosauridae)Maiasaura 相似的生长轨迹,尽管在大约 9 岁时达到了更大的渐近体型,这进一步表明整个分支可能继承了相似的生长策略。这个丰富的新数据集为埃德蒙顿龙属(Edmontosaurus)提供了对其他鸭嘴龙类生命史假说的新视角。当 RMDQ 种群与其他鸭嘴龙类骨骼床组合的大小分布进行比较时,幼体(分为 1 岁和 2 岁)在样本中完全缺失或严重不足,这为幼体和成年鸭嘴龙类之间的假设隔离提供了支持。与来自极地和温带地区的埃德蒙顿龙属(Edmontosaurus)的骨组织学比较表明,以前将骨组织学生长模式与环境胁迫强度相关联的结论是由于采样非重叠的个体发育生长阶段所致。