Zhang Jie, Xing Yingqi, Cui Li
Department of Neurology, Neuroscience Center, First Hospital of Jilin University, Jilin University, Changchun, China.
Department of Vascular Ultrasonography, Center of Vascular Ultrasonography, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Front Neurol. 2022 Jun 27;13:814972. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2022.814972. eCollection 2022.
Patients with symptomatic vertebral artery stenosis are at high risk of stroke recurrence, especially ≥70% stenosis. Revascularization may be considered for extracranial vertebral artery stenosis in patients with recurrent ischemic events despite optimal medical management. Currently, there is a lack of consensus on the ultrasonic evaluation of extracranial vertebral artery stenosis in clinical practice. This study aimed to validate the efficiency of duplex ultrasonography and assess the optimal sonographic thresholds for predicting extracranial vertebral artery stenosis.
This is a prospective study of all patients with symptomatic posterior circulation stroke/transient ischemic attack who were scheduled to undergo digital subtraction angiography from April 2020 to October 2021. A total of 544 vertebral arteries with a normal lumen or extracranial stenosis confirmed with digital subtraction angiography were included in the study. The peak systolic velocity at the V1 segment (PSVv1) and the V2 segment (PSVv2) were measured and the PSVv1/PSVv2 and PSVv2/PSVv1 ratios were calculated. The cutoff values were determined using receiver operating characteristic analysis.
The areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve of all the velocity parameters to predict extracranial vertebral artery stenosis were >0.80. The cutoff values for predicting ≥50% and ≥70% V1 segment stenosis were PSVv1 ≥146 cm/s (sensitivity 76.2%, specificity 86.3%) and PSVv1/PSVv2 ratio ≥2.2 (sensitivity 84.3%, specificity 77.6%), and PSVv1 ≥184 cm/s (sensitivity 80.8%, specificity 87.1%) and PSVv1/PSVv2 ratio ≥3.5 (sensitivity 79.5%, specificity 90.5%), respectively. The cutoff values for predicting ≥50% and ≥70% V2 segment stenosis were PSVv2 ≥80 cm/s (sensitivity 75.0%, specificity 91.0%) and PSVv2/PSVv1 ratio ≥1.2 (sensitivity 75.0%, specificity 94.8%), and PSVv2 ≥111 cm/s (sensitivity 81.0%, specificity 95.0%) and PSVv2/PSVv1 ratio ≥1.7 (sensitivity 81.0%, specificity 96.6%), respectively.
Symptomatic patients with the ultrasonic parameters of PSVv1 ≥146 cm/s and PSVv1/PSVv2 ratio ≥2.2 at V1 segment or PSVv2 ≥80 cm/s and PSVv2/PSVv1 ratio ≥1.2 at V2 segment need to be considered for further verification by digital subtraction angiography to seek revascularization. If the parameters increase to PSVv1 ≥184 cm/s and PSVv1/PSVv2 ratio ≥3.5 at the V1 segment or PSVv2 ≥111 cm/s and PSVv2/PSVv1 ratio ≥1.7 at the V2 segment, these patients have an increased risk of recurrent stroke and are more likely to need revascularization. The results can be used as a reference for the assessment and long-term management of patients with extracranial VA stenosis.
有症状的椎动脉狭窄患者发生中风复发的风险很高,尤其是狭窄程度≥70%的患者。尽管进行了最佳药物治疗,但对于反复出现缺血性事件的颅外椎动脉狭窄患者,可考虑进行血运重建。目前,临床实践中对颅外椎动脉狭窄的超声评估缺乏共识。本研究旨在验证双功超声检查的有效性,并评估预测颅外椎动脉狭窄的最佳超声阈值。
这是一项对2020年4月至2021年10月期间计划接受数字减影血管造影的所有有症状的后循环中风/短暂性脑缺血发作患者的前瞻性研究。共有544条经数字减影血管造影证实管腔正常或存在颅外狭窄的椎动脉纳入研究。测量V1段(PSVv1)和V2段(PSVv2)的收缩期峰值流速,并计算PSVv1/PSVv2和PSVv2/PSVv1比值。使用受试者工作特征分析确定临界值。
所有用于预测颅外椎动脉狭窄的流速参数的受试者工作特征曲线下面积均>0.80。预测V1段≥50%和≥70%狭窄的临界值分别为PSVv1≥146 cm/s(敏感性76.2%,特异性86.3%)和PSVv1/PSVv2比值≥2.2(敏感性84.3%,特异性77.6%),以及PSVv1≥184 cm/s(敏感性80.8%,特异性87.1%)和PSVv1/PSVv2比值≥3.5(敏感性79.5%,特异性90.5%)。预测V2段≥50%和≥70%狭窄的临界值分别为PSVv2≥80 cm/s(敏感性75.0%,特异性91.0%)和PSVv2/PSVv1比值≥1.2(敏感性75.0%,特异性94.8%),以及PSVv2≥111 cm/s(敏感性81.0%,特异性95.0%)和PSVv2/PSVv1比值≥1.7(敏感性81.0%,特异性96.6%)。
对于V1段超声参数为PSVv1≥146 cm/s且PSVv1/PSVv2比值≥2.2或V2段PSVv2≥80 cm/s且PSVv2/PSVv1比值≥1.2的有症状患者,需要考虑通过数字减影血管造影进行进一步验证以寻求血运重建。如果V1段参数增加到PSVv1≥184 cm/s且PSVv1/PSVv2比值≥3.5或V2段PSVv2≥111 cm/s且PSVv2/PSVv1比值≥1.7,这些患者中风复发风险增加,更有可能需要血运重建。这些结果可作为评估和长期管理颅外椎动脉狭窄患者的参考。