Orthopedic Surgery, Bærum Hospital, Vestre Viken Hospital Trust, Drammen, Norway
Institute of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
BMJ Open Qual. 2022 Jul;11(3). doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2022-001848.
Hip fractures are common, serious and costly fractures in the elderly population. Several guidelines seeking to ensure best practice have been introduced. Although our institution complied with national guidelines for early surgery of hip fractures, no assessment of other evidence-based measures existed. We wanted to assess, test, implement and measure the impact of a quality improvement (QI) programme consisting of key elements proven to be important in the treatment of hip fractures.
We formed a multidisciplinary QI team, consisting of several specialists in different fields. The QI team assessed multiple possible process measures for inclusion in the programme and selected six measurable interventions for implementation: early surgery, correct administration of prophylactic antibiotics, surgery using proven methods and expertise, a multidisciplinary patient pathway and secondary fracture prevention. The improvement process was monitored by a statistical process control chart (SPC). Complications, reoperations and mortality were compared before (n=293) and after (n=182) the intervention.
The SPC analyses indicated increasing adherence with all interventions throughout the improvement programme, and sustainability 7 years later. The last four periods showed a stable adherence above 90%. We found 60% reduction in major complications after the implementation of the improvement programme, from 19.1% to 7.7% (HR: 0.38 (95% CI: 0.23 to 0.61, p=0.0007). The need for reoperations due to complications fell from 12.6% to 4.9% (HR: 0.37 (95% CI: 0.21 to 0.67, p=0.0054). We did not find a difference in post-operative mortality after the implementation of the QI programme (HR: 0.95 (95% CI: 0.74 to 1.2, p=0.645).
Our multiprofessional improvement programme achieved almost full adherence within 2 years and was sustainable 7 years later. The quality and safety of the care process were improved and led to a substantial and sustainable decrease in complications and reoperations.
髋部骨折是老年人中常见的、严重的和高成本的骨折。已经引入了几项旨在确保最佳实践的指南。尽管我们的机构遵守了髋部骨折早期手术的国家指南,但不存在对其他基于证据的措施的评估。我们希望评估、测试、实施和衡量一个质量改进(QI)计划的影响,该计划包括在髋部骨折治疗中被证明很重要的关键要素。
我们成立了一个多学科的 QI 团队,由不同领域的几位专家组成。QI 团队评估了纳入该计划的多个可能的过程措施,并选择了六项可衡量的干预措施进行实施:早期手术、正确使用预防性抗生素、使用经过验证的方法和专业知识进行手术、多学科患者路径和继发性骨折预防。改进过程由统计过程控制图(SPC)进行监测。在干预之前(n=293)和之后(n=182)比较了并发症、再次手术和死亡率。
SPC 分析表明,在整个改进计划中,所有干预措施的依从性都在增加,并且在 7 年后仍然具有可持续性。最后四个时期显示稳定的依从性超过 90%。我们发现,实施改进计划后,主要并发症减少了 60%,从 19.1%降至 7.7%(HR:0.38(95%CI:0.23 至 0.61,p=0.0007)。由于并发症需要再次手术的比例从 12.6%降至 4.9%(HR:0.37(95%CI:0.21 至 0.67,p=0.0054)。我们没有发现实施 QI 计划后术后死亡率的差异(HR:0.95(95%CI:0.74 至 1.2,p=0.645)。
我们的多专业改进计划在 2 年内实现了几乎完全的依从性,并且在 7 年后仍然具有可持续性。护理过程的质量和安全性得到了提高,并导致并发症和再次手术的大幅和可持续减少。