Ashraf Mohammad, Choudhary Nabeel, Kamboh Usman Ahmad, Raza Muhammad Asif, Sultan Kashif Ali, Ghulam Naseeruddin, Hussain Syed Shahzad, Ashraf Naveed
Wolfson School of Medicine, University of Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom.
Department of Neurosurgery, Allama Iqbal Medical College, Jinnah Hospital Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan.
Surg Neurol Int. 2022 Jun 23;13:270. doi: 10.25259/SNI_250_2022. eCollection 2022.
Polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) cranioplasty, while widely prevalent, has limitations associated with freehand manual intraoperative molding. PMMA has been superseded by titanium or Polyetheretherketone implants, prefabricated commercially from preoperative CT scans, and boasting superior clinical and cosmetic outcomes. However, such services are extremely inaccessible and unaffordable in the lower-middle-income country (LMIC) settings. The study aims to describe, in detail, the process of making ultra-low-cost patient-specific PMMA cranioplasty implants with minimum resources using open-access software. We report the first such service from the public health-care system within Pakistan, a LMIC.
Using open-source software, preoperative CT heads were used to prefabricate three-dimensional implants. Both implant and cranial defects were printed using polylactic acid (PLA) to assess the implant's size and fit preoperatively. From the PLA implant, we fashioned a silicon mold that shapes the PMMA implant. Ten patients who underwent cranioplasty using our technique for various cranial defects with at least a 12-month follow-up were retrospectively reviewed. Clinical, cosmetic, and radiological outcomes were objectively assessed.
Etiology of injury was trauma (8), malignant MCA infarct (1), and arteriovenous fistula (1). We produced seven frontotemporal-parietal implants, one bifrontal, one frontal, and one frontoparietal. At 1 year, eight patients reported their cosmetic appearance comparable to before the defect. Radiological outcome was classified as "excellent" for eight patients. No postoperative complications were encountered, nor did any implant have to be removed. One patient's implant involving the orbital ridge had an unsatisfactory cosmetic outcome and required revision surgery. The average cost per implant to the National Health Service was US$40.
Prefabricated patient-specific PMMA cranioplasty implants are cost-effective. A single surgeon can fashion them in a limited resource setting and provide personalized medicine with excellent clinical/cosmetic-radiological results. Our method produces patient-specific cranioplasty implants in an otherwise unaffordable LMIC setting.
聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯(PMMA)颅骨成形术虽然广泛应用,但存在徒手术中塑形相关的局限性。PMMA已被钛或聚醚醚酮植入物取代,这些植入物由术前CT扫描商业预制而成,具有更好的临床和美容效果。然而,在中低收入国家(LMIC)环境中,此类服务极难获得且费用高昂。本研究旨在详细描述使用开放获取软件以最少资源制作超低成本患者特异性PMMA颅骨成形植入物的过程。我们报告了来自巴基斯坦(一个LMIC)公共卫生保健系统的首个此类服务。
使用开源软件,利用术前CT头颅数据预制三维植入物。植入物和颅骨缺损均使用聚乳酸(PLA)打印,以在术前评估植入物的尺寸和适配性。根据PLA植入物,制作了一个用于塑形PMMA植入物的硅模具。对10例使用我们的技术进行颅骨成形术治疗各种颅骨缺损且至少随访12个月的患者进行了回顾性研究。对临床、美容和放射学结果进行了客观评估。
损伤病因包括创伤(8例)、恶性大脑中动脉梗死(1例)和动静脉瘘(1例)。我们制作了7个额颞顶植入物、1个双额植入物、1个额部植入物和1个额顶植入物。1年后,8例患者报告其美容外观与缺损前相当。8例患者的放射学结果被分类为“优秀”。未遇到术后并发症,也无需取出任何植入物。1例涉及眶嵴的患者植入物美容效果不理想,需要进行翻修手术。国家卫生服务系统每个植入物的平均成本为40美元。
预制的患者特异性PMMA颅骨成形植入物具有成本效益。单个外科医生可以在资源有限的环境中制作这些植入物,并提供具有出色临床/美容 - 放射学结果的个性化医疗。我们的方法在原本难以承受的LMIC环境中生产患者特异性颅骨成形植入物。