Broffman Lauren, Harrison Sarah, Zhao Michael, Goldman Alex, Patnaik Ira, Zhou Megan
Roman Health Ventures, Inc., New York, New York, USA.
Telemed J E Health. 2023 Mar;29(3):425-431. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2022.0058. Epub 2022 Jul 22.
This study sought to examine the complex relationship between individual and environmental characteristics, broadband access, device type (computer or smartphone), and telehealth utilization as it relates to the digital divide. We analyzed a combination of electronic health record and publicly available zip code-level data for 2,770 men seeking treatment on a large, nationally available, direct-to-consumer telehealth platform. Using logistic regression, we determined the likelihood of accessing the platform through a smartphone (vs. a computer) based on key features of the environment, including broadband access and income, and demographic characteristics, including age and race. We found that living in areas with higher rates of broadband adoption significantly decreased the likelihood of accessing virtual care using a smartphone (odds ratio [OR] = 0.17, < 0.001). Compared with the 18-29 age category, the odds of accessing virtual care using a smartphone decreased for men between the age categories of 40-59 (OR = 0.63, < 0.01) and over 60 (OR = 0.29, < 0.001) years. Belonging to historically marginalized communities of color (Black, Hispanic, and Native American) almost doubled the odds of using a smartphone to access the platform (OR = 1.8, < 0.001). Broadband availability and median area income were not significantly associated with mobile use. Telehealth platform design and policy solutions intended to expand access to virtual care should be flexible enough to accommodate the sometimes competing needs of patients who are at the greatest risk of being left behind.
本研究旨在探讨个体特征与环境特征、宽带接入、设备类型(电脑或智能手机)以及远程医疗利用之间的复杂关系,及其与数字鸿沟的关联。我们分析了电子健康记录和公开可用的邮政编码级数据的组合,这些数据来自于在一个大型的、全国可用的直接面向消费者的远程医疗平台上寻求治疗的2770名男性。通过逻辑回归,我们根据环境的关键特征(包括宽带接入和收入)以及人口统计学特征(包括年龄和种族),确定了通过智能手机(与电脑相比)访问该平台的可能性。我们发现,生活在宽带采用率较高地区的人使用智能手机进行虚拟护理的可能性显著降低(优势比[OR]=0.17,<0.001)。与18 - 29岁年龄组相比,40 - 59岁(OR = 0.63,<0.01)和60岁以上(OR = 0.29,<0.001)的男性使用智能手机进行虚拟护理的几率降低。属于历史上被边缘化的有色人种社区(黑人、西班牙裔和美国原住民)使用智能手机访问该平台的几率几乎翻倍(OR = 1.8,<0.001)。宽带可用性和地区收入中位数与移动使用没有显著关联。旨在扩大虚拟护理可及性的远程医疗平台设计和政策解决方案应足够灵活,以满足那些最有可能被落下的患者有时相互冲突的需求。