Associate Dentist, Richmond Dental Care, Sheffield S13 8LU, UK.
Academic Clinical Fellow in Primary Dental Care, University of Sheffield, UK.
Br Dent J. 2022 Jul;233(2):141-147. doi: 10.1038/s41415-022-4457-6. Epub 2022 Jul 22.
Introduction The General Dental Council has advised that undergraduate dental students spend time in primary care, with their experiences evaluated. A systematic review of medical students' primary care placements has been performed but no similar review of dental students is present. This review aimed to synthesise reported opinions of UK dental students on their placements in primary care.Methods Medline, Embase, Education Resources Information Center and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched for qualitative data studies involving UK dental students who had been on placement during training. The qualitative Critical Appraisal Skills Programme guidance was used to appraise studies and a best fit framework synthesis employed.Results Students generally portrayed positive accounts of placements. Themes relating to learning environment, support for learning, real world dentistry, preparation for practice life and competing cultures were developed.Discussion Students thrived when hierarchy between themselves and their supervisors was flattened but the competing cultures of the dental hospital and placements appear to be an area that needs addressing. There are vast differences in the placements being offered.Conclusions Undergraduates mostly enjoy and value their time on placement; however, further research in the area is needed to explore the different kinds of placements available and to inform policy on providing effective training.
简介 英国牙科理事会建议本科生在初级保健领域实习,并对其经验进行评估。已经对医学生的初级保健实习进行了系统评价,但没有针对牙科学生的类似评价。本综述旨在综合英国牙科学生对其在初级保健领域实习的报告意见。
方法 检索了 Medline、Embase、教育资源信息中心和 Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature,以获取涉及英国牙科学生在培训期间实习的定性数据研究。使用定性批判性评估技能计划指南对研究进行评估,并采用最佳拟合框架综合。
结果 学生们普遍对实习经历给予了积极的评价。发展出与学习环境、学习支持、现实世界的牙科、实践生活准备和竞争文化相关的主题。
讨论 当他们与主管之间的层级关系被削弱时,学生们表现出色,但牙科医院和实习之间的竞争文化似乎是一个需要解决的问题。提供的实习机会存在巨大差异。
结论 本科生大多喜欢并重视他们在实习期间的时间;然而,需要在该领域进行进一步研究,以探索不同类型的实习机会,并为提供有效的培训提供政策建议。