Baig Naila, Siddiqui Faiza, Baig Mirza Altamish Muhammad, Khursheed Iram, Meah Khubaib Muhammad Shamim
Directorate of Educational Development, Ziauddin University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Department of Medical Education, Liaquat College of Medicine and Dentistry, Karachi, Pakistan.
Can Med Educ J. 2022 Jul 6;13(3):84-90. doi: 10.36834/cmej.73910. eCollection 2022 Jul.
Diverse strategies are employed globally to integrate medical curricula. Nevertheless, a gap exists in assessing the role of medical instructors in meaningful integration. We developed and used a tool to explore the current level of integration, score medical instructors' individual practices for integration, and investigate contextual elements minimizing integration.
This cross-sectional study, conducted in September-November-2020, used convenience-sampling. The study participants were basic-sciences and clinical instructors at two private-sector medical colleges in Karachi-Pakistan (with a response rate of 53.5%, = 107). We validated a paper-based questionnaire through a pilot study on five participants. This tool with 11 close-ended questions on a 5-point Likert scale generated instructors' integration scores, and six open-ended questions probed instructors' perspectives.
The mean integration score was 37.4±6.7. Participants' perspectives indicated a need for participation of clinical faculty in teaching initial undergraduate years, involving lecturers in curriculum meetings, and integration of assessment. The questionnaire Cronbach-alpha was 0.732 with satisfactory principal-component-analysis.
Medical instructors facilitated integration mainly through concurrent timetabling of similar topics. Moreover, formal consultation through committee meetings, with discipline-based and integrated approaches complementing each other, were in practice to achieve curricular goals.
全球采用了多种策略来整合医学课程。然而,在评估医学教师在有意义的整合中的作用方面存在差距。我们开发并使用了一种工具来探索当前的整合水平,对医学教师的个人整合实践进行评分,并调查阻碍整合的背景因素。
这项横断面研究于2020年9月至11月进行,采用便利抽样。研究参与者是巴基斯坦卡拉奇两所私立医学院的基础科学和临床教师(回复率为53.5%,n = 107)。我们通过对五名参与者的预试验验证了一份纸质问卷。这个工具包含11个基于5点李克特量表的封闭式问题,用于生成教师的整合分数,还有6个开放式问题用于探究教师的观点。
平均整合分数为37.4±6.7。参与者的观点表明,需要临床教师参与本科低年级的教学,让讲师参与课程会议,并整合评估。问卷的克朗巴哈系数为0.732,主成分分析结果令人满意。
医学教师主要通过同时安排相似主题的课程来促进整合。此外,通过委员会会议进行正式协商,基于学科的方法和整合方法相互补充,以实现课程目标。