Kociewskie Centrum Zdrowia, Starogard Gdanski, Poland.
Academy of Applied Medical and Social Sciences, Elblag, Poland.
Ginekol Pol. 2023;94(4):315-319. doi: 10.5603/GP.a2022.0039. Epub 2022 Jul 27.
The aim of the study was to compare maternal and neonatal outcome of delivery with inhaled anesthesia to delivery without pain control.
Authors performed retrospective analysis of 260 term deliveries. In the study group (130 women) a mixture of nitrous oxide and oxygen was used. The control group included 130 patients who used no pain relief during delivery.
In nulliparas the pain assessment in 11-points scale was similar in both groups, but the labor was longer (350 ± 152 vs 228 ± 113 minutes; p < 0.001 for the first stage and 46 ± 37 vs 18 ± 18 minutes; p < 0.001 for the second stage), episiotomy incidence was higher (81.4% vs 41.9%; p < 0.001) and perineal laceration lower (2.3% vs 25.7%; p < 0.001) in the study group. In multiparas the pain assessment was lower in the study group (5 vs 7 points; p = 0.006), oxytocin was administered more frequently (45.5% vs 21.4%, p = 0.011), but labor duration was the same in both groups. Episiotomy was more frequent (61.4% vs 37.5%, p = 0.02), but there was no difference in perineal laceration. Apgar score was the same in the study and control group.
We found that Entonox prolongs labor significantly and increases frequency of episiotomy in primiparas with no clear analgesic effect. Offering Entonox to the patients giving birth for the first time is thus questionable. In multiparas it has a good analgesic effect but increases probability of episiotomy with no significant influence on perineal tear, what seems not very high cost of decreased pain related to delivery.
本研究旨在比较吸入麻醉分娩与无疼痛控制分娩的母婴结局。
作者对 260 例足月分娩进行了回顾性分析。在研究组(130 例妇女)中使用了一氧化二氮和氧气的混合物。对照组包括 130 例分娩时未使用任何止痛药物的患者。
在初产妇中,两组在 11 分制疼痛评估中相似,但第一产程较长(350 ± 152 分钟对 228 ± 113 分钟;p < 0.001),第二产程较长(46 ± 37 分钟对 18 ± 18 分钟;p < 0.001),会阴切开率较高(81.4%对 41.9%;p < 0.001),会阴裂伤率较低(2.3%对 25.7%;p < 0.001)。在经产妇中,研究组疼痛评估较低(5 分对 7 分;p = 0.006),催产素使用更为频繁(45.5%对 21.4%;p = 0.011),但两组产程相同。会阴切开术更为频繁(61.4%对 37.5%;p = 0.02),但会阴裂伤无差异。两组新生儿阿普加评分相同。
我们发现,氧化亚氮显著延长了初产妇的产程,增加了会阴切开术的频率,但没有明显的镇痛效果。因此,对于首次分娩的患者提供氧化亚氮是值得商榷的。在经产妇中,它具有良好的镇痛效果,但增加了会阴切开术的可能性,对会阴撕裂没有显著影响,这似乎是降低分娩相关疼痛的代价不高。