Eggimann B, Paccaud F, Gutzwiller F
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1987 May 16;117(20):747-55.
All patients having undergone a coronarography during 1984 have been surveyed in Switzerland. This retrospective study has used existing data in the 13 centers practicing this diagnostic procedure. 4921 coronarographies were carried out in 1984, amongst 4359 patients. In terms of population-based rates, the national figures are 77 procedures/100,000 residents, and 68 patients/100,000 residents. Female rates are one fourth of the male rates (27/100,000 versus 112/100,000). For both sexes, the highest utilization rates are for the age groups 60-64. Swiss figures are relatively low when compared with other developed countries. However, patterns of utilization are very different within the country: according to the Canton of residence of the patient, the utilization rates (standardized for age and sex) vary from 8/100,000 to 160/100,000. There is a distinct gradient from south-west to north-east, which closely corresponds to the distribution of centers practicing the procedure. More intriguing is the fact that cardiovascular mortality shows an inverse geographical gradient, with the highest mortality in Cantons having the lowest rate of coronarography. Various reasons for the observed variations are discussed, in relation with differences in supply of diagnostic and therapeutic equipments, but also in relation with various patterns of demand related to differential morbidity rates and/or differential patterns of clinical decision.
1984年期间在瑞士接受冠状动脉造影检查的所有患者都接受了调查。这项回顾性研究使用了13个进行该诊断程序的中心的现有数据。1984年对4359名患者进行了4921次冠状动脉造影检查。以基于人群的比率计算,全国数据为每10万居民中有77次检查,每10万居民中有68名患者。女性比率是男性比率的四分之一(27/10万对112/10万)。对于两性来说,60 - 64岁年龄组的利用率最高。与其他发达国家相比,瑞士的数据相对较低。然而,国内的利用模式差异很大:根据患者居住的州,利用率(按年龄和性别标准化)从8/10万到160/10万不等。从西南到东北有明显的梯度,这与进行该程序的中心分布密切对应。更有趣的是,心血管死亡率呈现出相反的地理梯度,冠状动脉造影检查率最低的州死亡率最高。文中讨论了观察到的这些差异的各种原因,这些差异与诊断和治疗设备供应的差异有关,也与因发病率差异和/或临床决策模式差异而产生的各种需求模式有关。