Departments of1Neurological Surgery.
2Radiology, and.
Neurosurg Focus. 2022 Jul;53(1):E6. doi: 10.3171/2022.4.FOCUS2288.
Seizures are the second most common presenting symptom of brain arteriovenous malformations (bAVMs) after hemorrhage. Risk factors for preoperative seizures and subsequent seizure control outcomes have been well studied. There is a paucity of literature on postoperative, de novo seizures in initially seizure-naïve patients who undergo resection. Whereas this entity has been documented after craniotomy for a wide variety of neurosurgically treated pathologies including tumors, trauma, and aneurysms, de novo seizures after bAVM resection are poorly studied. Given the debilitating nature of epilepsy, the purpose of this study was to elucidate the incidence and risk factors associated with de novo epilepsy after bAVM resection.
A retrospective review of patients who underwent resection of a bAVM over a 15-year period was performed. Patients who did not present with seizure were included, and the primary outcome was de novo epilepsy (i.e., a seizure disorder that only manifested after surgery). Demographic, clinical, and radiographic characteristics were compared between patients with and without postoperative epilepsy. Subgroup analysis was conducted on the ruptured bAVMs.
From a cohort of 198 patients who underwent resection of a bAVM during the study period, 111 supratentorial ruptured and unruptured bAVMs that did not present with seizure were included. Twenty-one patients (19%) developed de novo epilepsy. One-year cumulative rates of developing de novo epilepsy were 9% for the overall cohort and 8.5% for the cohort with ruptured bAVMs. There were no significant differences between the epilepsy and no-epilepsy groups overall; however, the de novo epilepsy group was younger in the cohort with ruptured bAVMs (28.7 ± 11.7 vs 35.1 ± 19.9 years; p = 0.04). The mean time between resection and first seizure was 26.0 ± 40.4 months, with the longest time being 14 years. Subgroup analysis of the ruptured and endovascular embolization cohorts did not reveal any significant differences. Of the patients who developed poorly controlled epilepsy (defined as Engel class III-IV), all had a history of hemorrhage and half had bAVMs located in the temporal lobe.
De novo epilepsy after bAVM resection occurs at an annual cumulative risk of 9%, with potentially long-term onset. Younger age may be a risk factor in patients who present with rupture. The development of poorly controlled epilepsy may be associated with temporal lobe location and a delay between hemorrhage and resection.
癫痫发作是脑动静脉畸形(bAVM)继出血后第二常见的首发症状。术前癫痫发作的危险因素及其后续的癫痫发作控制结果已有大量研究。然而,对于最初无癫痫发作的患者,在接受切除术后新发的术后癫痫发作,文献报道较少。尽管这种情况已经在各种神经外科治疗的病变中记录下来,包括肿瘤、创伤和动脉瘤,在 bAVM 切除术后新出现的癫痫发作研究较少。鉴于癫痫的致残性质,本研究旨在阐明与 bAVM 切除术后新发癫痫相关的发病率和危险因素。
对 15 年来接受 bAVM 切除术的患者进行回顾性分析。包括无癫痫发作的患者,主要结局是新发癫痫(即仅在手术后出现的癫痫发作障碍)。比较术后有癫痫发作和无癫痫发作患者的人口统计学、临床和影像学特征。对破裂性 bAVM 进行亚组分析。
在研究期间接受 bAVM 切除术的 198 例患者中,纳入了 111 例幕上破裂和未破裂的 bAVM,这些患者术前无癫痫发作。21 例(19%)出现新发癫痫。总体队列的 1 年累积新发癫痫发生率为 9%,破裂性 bAVM 队列的发生率为 8.5%。总体上,癫痫组和非癫痫组之间无显著差异;然而,在破裂性 bAVM 队列中,新发癫痫组的年龄较小(28.7±11.7 岁比 35.1±19.9 岁;p=0.04)。切除与首次癫痫发作之间的平均时间为 26.0±40.4 个月,最长时间为 14 年。对破裂性和血管内栓塞亚组的分析未发现任何显著差异。在出现难治性癫痫(定义为 Engel Ⅲ-Ⅳ级)的患者中,所有患者均有出血史,半数患者的 bAVM 位于颞叶。
bAVM 切除术后新发癫痫的年累积风险为 9%,可能有长期发作。在破裂性 bAVM 患者中,年龄较小可能是一个危险因素。在出血和切除之间存在时间延迟的情况下,控制不佳的癫痫可能与颞叶位置有关。