Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
WHO Collaborating Centre for Governance, Accountability and Transparency in the Pharmaceutical Sector, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
PLoS One. 2022 Aug 2;17(8):e0269203. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0269203. eCollection 2022.
Corruption is a global wicked problem that threatens the achievement of health, social and economic development goals, including Sustainable Development Goal # 3: Ensuring healthy lives and promoting well-being for all. The COVID-19 pandemic and its resulting strain on health systems has heightened risks of corruption both generally and specifically within health systems. Over the past years, international organizations, including those instrumental to the global COVID-19 response, have increased efforts to address corruption within their operations and related programs. However, as attention to anti-corruption efforts is relatively recent within international organizations, there is a lack of literature examining how these organizations address corruption and the impact of their anti-corruption efforts. This study addresses this gap by examining how accountability, transparency, and anti-corruption are taken up by international organizations within their own operations and the reported outcomes of such efforts. The following international organizations were selected as the focus of this document analysis: the World Health Organization, the Global Fund, the United Nations Development Programme, and the World Bank Group. Documents were identified through a targeted search of each organization's website. Documents were then analyzed combining elements of content analysis and thematic analysis. The findings demonstrate that accountability and transparency mechanisms have been employed by each of the four international organizations to address corruption. Further, these organizations commonly employed oversight mechanisms, including risk assessments, investigations, and audits to monitor their internal and external operations for fraud and corruption. All organizations used sanction strategies meant to reprimand identified transgressors and deter future corruption. Findings also demonstrate a marked increase in anti-corruption efforts by these international organizations in recent years. Though this is promising, there remains a distinct absence of evidence demonstrating the impact of such efforts on the prevalence and severity of corruption in international organizations.
腐败是一个全球性的恶性问题,威胁着健康、社会和经济发展目标的实现,包括可持续发展目标 3:确保健康的生活并促进所有人的福祉。COVID-19 大流行及其对卫生系统造成的压力增加了腐败的风险,无论是在一般情况下还是在卫生系统内。在过去几年中,包括对全球 COVID-19 应对至关重要的国际组织在内,都加大了努力,以解决其运营和相关计划中的腐败问题。然而,由于国际组织对反腐败工作的关注相对较新,因此缺乏研究这些组织如何处理腐败问题及其反腐败工作影响的文献。本研究通过检查国际组织在其自身运营中如何采用问责制、透明度和反腐败措施,以及这些努力的报告结果,来填补这一空白。本文件分析选择了以下国际组织作为重点:世界卫生组织、全球基金、联合国开发计划署和世界银行集团。通过有针对性地搜索每个组织的网站,确定了文件。然后,通过内容分析和主题分析的要素相结合对文件进行了分析。研究结果表明,四个国际组织中的每一个都采用了问责制和透明度机制来解决腐败问题。此外,这些组织通常采用监督机制,包括风险评估、调查和审计,以监测其内部和外部业务中的欺诈和腐败行为。所有组织都采用制裁策略,旨在谴责已确定的违规者,并阻止未来的腐败行为。研究结果还表明,近年来,这些国际组织加大了反腐败力度。尽管这是有希望的,但仍然缺乏证据表明这些努力对国际组织腐败的普遍性和严重程度产生了影响。