Miller McKenzie B, Gabel Shelley A, Gluf-Magar Lindsay C, Haan Pam S, Lin Judith C, Clarkson James H W
Department of Surgery, Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, East Lansing, Mich.
Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2022 Jul 13;10(7):e4426. doi: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000004426. eCollection 2022 Jul.
This study examined how wide- awake local anesthesia no tourniquet (WALANT) surgery in the office versus the standard operating room (OR) impacts patient experience, and the effect wide awake virtual reality (WAVR) has in conjunction with WALANT on patient experience.
This is a patient-reported outcome study of patients undergoing carpal tunnel release by a single surgeon between August 2017 and March 2021. Patients were classified by location; traditional OR versus WALANT in-office. In-office patients were further classified by whether they chose to use WAVR or not. Patients rated overall experience, enjoyability, and anxiety using a Likert scale (1-7).
The online survey had a 44.8% response rate. OR patients were twice as likely to report a neutral or negative experience (23% versus 11%, = 0.03), significantly lower enjoyment scores (44% versus 20%, = 0.0007)' and higher anxiety (42% versus 26%, = 0.04) compared with office-based WALANT patients. With the addition of WAVR, office patients reported higher enjoyment than those who did not use WAVR (85% versus 73%, = 0.05). Patients reporting an anxiety disorder were more likely to choose WAVR when compared with patients without anxiety disorder (73.8% versus 56.4%). When they chose WAVR, they had greater anxiolysis (79% versus 47%, = 0.01)' and increased enjoyment (90% versus 59%, = 0.005).
This study demonstrates improved patient experience in the office setting, further amplified by WAVR. Preexisting anxiety disorder is a positive predictive variable toward the patients' choice to use WAVR.
本研究探讨了门诊清醒局部麻醉无止血带(WALANT)手术与标准手术室(OR)手术相比对患者体验的影响,以及清醒虚拟现实(WAVR)与WALANT联合应用对患者体验的作用。
这是一项患者报告结局研究,研究对象为2017年8月至2021年3月间由单一外科医生进行腕管松解术的患者。患者按手术地点分类;传统手术室手术与门诊WALANT手术。门诊患者再根据是否选择使用WAVR进一步分类。患者使用李克特量表(1 - 7)对总体体验、愉悦度和焦虑程度进行评分。
在线调查的回复率为44.8%。与门诊WALANT手术患者相比,手术室手术患者报告中性或负面体验的可能性高出两倍(23%对11%,P = 0.03),愉悦度得分显著更低(44%对20%,P = 0.0007),焦虑程度更高(42%对26%,P = 0.04)。加上WAVR后,门诊患者报告的愉悦度高于未使用WAVR的患者(85%对73%,P = 0.05)。与无焦虑症的患者相比,报告患有焦虑症的患者更有可能选择WAVR(73.8%对56.4%)。当他们选择WAVR时,焦虑缓解程度更大(79%对47%,P = 0.01),愉悦度增加(90%对59%,P = 0.005)。
本研究表明门诊手术患者体验更佳,WAVR可进一步增强这种效果。既往焦虑症是患者选择使用WAVR的一个正向预测变量。