Takahashi Tsukasa, Jobe Alan H, Fee Erin L, Newnham John P, Schmidt Augusto F, Usuda Haruo, Kemp Matthew W
Division of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Western Australia, Perth, Australia; Center for Perinatal and Neonatal Medicine, Tohoku University Hospital, Sendai, Japan.
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Cincinnati School of Medicine, Cincinnati, OH.
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2022 Nov;227(5):696-704. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2022.07.030. Epub 2022 Aug 3.
Antenatal steroid therapy is standard care for women at imminent risk of preterm delivery. When deliveries occur within 7 days of treatment, antenatal steroid therapy reduces the risk of neonatal death and improves preterm outcomes by exerting diverse developmental effects on the fetal organs, in particular the preterm lung and cardiovascular system. There is, however, sizable variability in antenatal steroid treatment efficacy, and an important percentage of fetuses exposed to antenatal steroid therapy do not respond sufficiently to derive benefit. Respiratory distress syndrome, for example, is a central metric of clinical trials to assess antenatal steroid outcomes. In the present analysis, we addressed the concept of antenatal steroid nonresponsiveness, and defined a failed or suboptimal response to antenatal steroids as death or a diagnosis of respiratory distress syndrome following treatment. For deliveries at 24 to 35 weeks' gestation, the number needed to treat to prevent 1 case of respiratory distress syndrome was 19 (95% confidence interval, 14-28). Reflecting gestation-dependent risk, for deliveries at >34 weeks' gestation the number needed to treat was 55 (95% confidence interval, 30-304), whereas for elective surgical deliveries at term this number was 106 (95% confidence interval, 61-421). We reviewed data from clinical and animal studies investigating antenatal steroid therapy to highlight the significant incidence of antenatal steroid therapy nonresponsiveness (ie, residual mortality or respiratory distress syndrome after treatment), and the potential mechanisms underpinning this outcome variability. The origins of this variability may be related to both the manner in which the therapy is applied (ie, the treatment regimen itself) and factors specific to the individual (ie, genetic variation, stress, infection). The primary aims of this review were: (1) to emphasize to the obstetrical and neonatal communities the extent of antenatal steroid response variability and its potential impact; (2) to propose approaches by which antenatal steroid therapy may be better applied to improve overall benefit; and (3) to stimulate further research toward the empirical optimization of this important antenatal therapy.
产前类固醇疗法是即将早产的孕妇的标准治疗方法。当在治疗后7天内分娩时,产前类固醇疗法可降低新生儿死亡风险,并通过对胎儿器官,特别是早产肺和心血管系统产生多种发育影响,改善早产结局。然而,产前类固醇治疗效果存在相当大的差异,并且接受产前类固醇疗法的胎儿中有相当一部分没有得到足够的反应而无法获益。例如,呼吸窘迫综合征是评估产前类固醇治疗效果的临床试验的核心指标。在本分析中,我们探讨了产前类固醇无反应性的概念,并将对产前类固醇的无效或次优反应定义为治疗后死亡或诊断为呼吸窘迫综合征。对于妊娠24至35周的分娩,预防1例呼吸窘迫综合征所需的治疗人数为19(95%置信区间,14-28)。反映出与孕周相关的风险,对于妊娠>34周的分娩,所需治疗人数为55(95%置信区间,30-304),而对于足月择期手术分娩,这一数字为106(95%置信区间,61-421)。我们回顾了研究产前类固醇疗法的临床和动物研究数据,以突出产前类固醇疗法无反应性的高发生率(即治疗后仍有残留死亡率或呼吸窘迫综合征)以及导致这种结果差异的潜在机制。这种差异的根源可能与治疗应用方式(即治疗方案本身)和个体特异性因素(即基因变异、应激、感染)有关。本综述的主要目的是:(1)向产科和新生儿学界强调产前类固醇反应差异的程度及其潜在影响;(2)提出可更好应用产前类固醇疗法以提高总体获益的方法;(3)激发对这一重要产前治疗进行经验性优化的进一步研究。