Department of Internal Medicine IV, Justus-Liebig-University, Universities of Giessen and Marburg Lung Centre (UGMLC), Klinikstrasse 33, 35392, Giessen, Germany.
BMC Palliat Care. 2022 Aug 12;21(1):144. doi: 10.1186/s12904-022-01035-x.
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has challenged health care systems worldwide. In Germany, patients in a palliative care setting have the opportunity to receive treatment by a specialised mobile outpatient palliative care team (OPC). The given retrospective single centre analysis describes the use of OPC structures for terminally ill COVID-19 patients during the height of the pandemic in Germany and aims to characterise this exceptional OPC patient collective.
First, death certificates were analysed in order to collect data about the place of death of all deceased COVID-19 patients (n = 471) within our local governance district. Second, we investigated whether advance care planning structures were established in local nursing homes (n = 30) during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. Third, we examined patient characteristics of COVID-19 negative (n = 1579) and COVID-19 positive (n = 28) patients treated by our tertiary care centre guided OPC service.
The analysis of death certificates in our local district revealed that only 2.1% of all deceased COVID-19 patients had succumbed at their home address (n = 10/471). In contrast, 34.0% of COVID-19 patients died in nursing homes (n = 160/471), whereas 63.5% died in an inpatient hospital setting (n = 299/471). A large proportion of these hospitalised patients died on non-intensive care unit wards (38.8%). Approximately 33.0% of surveyed nursing homes had a palliative care council service and 40.0% of them offered advance care planning (ACP) structures for their nursing home residents. In our two OPC collectives we observed significant differences concerning clinical characteristics such as the Index of Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group [ECOG] (p = 0.014), oncologic comorbidity (p = 0.004), as well as referrer and primary patient location (p = 0.001, p = 0.033).
Most COVID-19 patients in our governance district died in an inpatient setting. However, the highest number of COVID-19 patients in our governance district who died in an outpatient setting passed away in nursing homes where palliative care structures should be further expanded. COVID-19 patients who died under the care of our OPC service had considerably fewer oncologic comorbidities. Finally, to relieve conventional health care structures, we propose the expansion of established OPC structures for treating terminally ill COVID-19 patients.
2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行对全球卫生保健系统提出了挑战。在德国,姑息治疗环境中的患者有机会接受专门的移动姑息治疗门诊团队(OPC)的治疗。本回顾性单中心分析描述了在德国 COVID-19 大流行高峰期,OPC 结构在终末期 COVID-19 患者中的使用情况,并旨在描述这一特殊的 OPC 患者群体。
首先,分析死亡证明以收集我们当地行政区内所有死亡的 COVID-19 患者(n=471)的死亡地点数据。其次,我们调查了在 2020 年 COVID-19 大流行高峰期,当地养老院是否建立了预先护理计划结构(n=30)。第三,我们检查了我们的三级护理中心指导的 OPC 服务治疗的 COVID-19 阴性(n=1579)和 COVID-19 阳性(n=28)患者的患者特征。
对我们当地地区的死亡证明进行分析表明,所有死亡的 COVID-19 患者中只有 2.1%(n=10/471)在其家庭住址去世。相比之下,34.0%(n=160/471)的 COVID-19 患者在养老院死亡,而 63.5%(n=299/471)在住院医院死亡。这些住院患者中有很大一部分(38.8%)在非重症监护病房死亡。大约 33.0%的被调查养老院有姑息治疗委员会服务,40.0%的养老院为其养老院居民提供预先护理计划(ACP)结构。在我们的两个 OPC 群体中,我们观察到临床特征方面存在显著差异,例如东部合作肿瘤学组(ECOG)指数(p=0.014)、肿瘤合并症(p=0.004)、转诊医生和主要患者所在地(p=0.001,p=0.033)。
我们行政区内的大多数 COVID-19 患者在住院期间死亡。然而,我们行政区内在门诊环境中死亡的 COVID-19 患者中,有相当一部分是在姑息治疗结构应进一步扩大的养老院中去世的。在我们的 OPC 服务下死亡的 COVID-19 患者肿瘤合并症明显较少。最后,为了缓解常规医疗保健结构的压力,我们建议扩大为治疗终末期 COVID-19 患者而建立的 OPC 结构。