Sait Saif, Havariyoun Glafkos, Newman Howard, Das Sreena, Haque Saira
Department of Radiology, Kings College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Denmark Hill, London, SE5 9RS, UK.
Department of Medical Engineering, Physics and Radiation Protection, Kings College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK.
Pediatr Radiol. 2023 Jan;53(1):69-77. doi: 10.1007/s00247-022-05477-6. Epub 2022 Aug 17.
A skeletal survey is an important diagnostic tool for patients presenting with suspected physical abuse. A relatively recent change in guidelines for skeletal surveys by the Royal College of Radiologists (RCR) in 2017 has led to more initial and follow-up images for these patients, which would be expected to have led to an increase in effective radiation dose.
To estimate the effective dose following the change in guidelines and to ascertain the difference between doses before and after the change in guidelines.
Data were collected retrospectively on children younger than 3 years old referred for skeletal surveys for suspected physical abuse at a tertiary paediatric centre. A Monte Carlo radiation patient dose simulation software, PCXMC v 2.0.1, was used to estimate the effective dose, expressed in millisieverts (mSv).
Sixty-eight children underwent skeletal surveys for suspected physical abuse. The total estimated effective dose for skeletal surveys with the previous RCR guidelines was found to be 0.19 mSv. For initial skeletal surveys with the current RCR guidelines, the estimated effective radiation dose was 0.19 mSv. Eighteen children had both initial and follow-up skeletal surveys as indicated by the current RCR guidelines, with an estimated effective total radiation dose of 0.26 mSv.
Skeletal surveys deliver a relatively low estimated effective radiation dose equivalent to 1 month of United Kingdom background radiation, with no significant change in dose following the change in guidelines. Therefore, the benefits of having a skeletal survey outweigh the main radiation risk. However, accurate data regarding the radiation dose are important for clinicians consenting parents/guardians for imaging in suspected physical abuse.
骨骼检查是疑似身体虐待患者的重要诊断工具。英国皇家放射科医师学院(RCR)在2017年对骨骼检查指南进行了相对较新的修订,这导致此类患者的初始和随访影像增多,预计有效辐射剂量会增加。
估计指南修订后的有效剂量,并确定指南修订前后剂量的差异。
回顾性收集在一家三级儿科中心因疑似身体虐待而接受骨骼检查的3岁以下儿童的数据。使用蒙特卡罗辐射患者剂量模拟软件PCXMC v 2.0.1来估计有效剂量,以毫西弗(mSv)表示。
68名儿童因疑似身体虐待接受了骨骼检查。根据RCR之前的指南,骨骼检查的总估计有效剂量为0.19 mSv。根据RCR当前的指南,初始骨骼检查的估计有效辐射剂量为0.19 mSv。按照RCR当前的指南,18名儿童进行了初始和随访骨骼检查,估计总有效辐射剂量为0.26 mSv。
骨骼检查的估计有效辐射剂量相对较低,相当于英国背景辐射1个月的剂量,指南修订后剂量无显著变化。因此,进行骨骼检查的益处超过主要的辐射风险。然而,对于在疑似身体虐待情况下为家长/监护人提供影像检查同意书的临床医生而言,有关辐射剂量的准确数据很重要。