Ruddy T D, Dighero H R, Newell J B, Pohost G M, Strauss H W, Okada R D, Boucher C A
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1987 Jul;10(1):142-9. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(87)80172-9.
To determine if the detection of coronary artery disease by dipyridamole-thallium imaging is improved by quantitative versus qualitative analysis, and combining quantitative variables, 80 patients with chest pain (53 with and 27 without coronary artery disease) who underwent cardiac catheterization were studied. Segmental thallium initial uptake, linear clearance, monoexponential clearance and redistribution were measured from early, intermediate and delayed images acquired in three projections. Normal values were determined from 13 other clinically normal subjects. When five segments per view were used for quantitative analysis, sensitivity and specificity were 87 and 63%, respectively, for uptake, 77 and 67% for linear clearance, 60 and 60% for monoexponential clearance and 62 and 56% for redistribution. Of the four variables, uptake and linear clearance were the most sensitive (p less than 0.01) and specificity did not differ significantly. Using three segments per view, the specificity of uptake increased (p less than 0.05) to 78% without a significant change in sensitivity (85%). With this approach, sensitivity and specificity did not differ from those of qualitative analysis (85 and 78%, respectively). Stepwise logistic regression analysis demonstrated that the best quantitative thallium correlate of the presence of coronary artery disease was a combination variable of "either abnormal uptake or abnormal linear clearance, or both." Using five segments per view, the model's specificity (85%) was greater than that of uptake alone (p less than 0.02), with similar sensitivity (92%). Using three segments per view, the model's specificity (93%) was greater than that of uptake alone (p less than 0.05) and of qualitative analysis (p less than 0.05), with similar sensitivity (85%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为了确定通过双嘧达莫-铊心肌显像检测冠心病时,定量分析与定性分析以及结合定量变量是否能提高检测效果,我们对80例因胸痛接受心导管检查的患者进行了研究(其中53例患有冠心病,27例未患冠心病)。从三个投照角度获取的早期、中期和延迟图像中测量节段性铊初始摄取、线性清除、单指数清除和再分布情况。从另外13名临床正常受试者确定正常值。当每个视野使用5个节段进行定量分析时,摄取的敏感性和特异性分别为87%和63%,线性清除为77%和67%,单指数清除为60%和60%,再分布为62%和56%。在这四个变量中,摄取和线性清除最敏感(p<0.01),特异性无显著差异。每个视野使用3个节段时,摄取的特异性增加(p<0.05)至78%,敏感性无显著变化(85%)。采用这种方法,敏感性和特异性与定性分析(分别为85%和78%)无差异。逐步逻辑回归分析表明,冠心病存在的最佳定量铊相关因素是“摄取异常或线性清除异常,或两者皆异常”的组合变量。每个视野使用5个节段时,该模型的特异性(85%)高于单独摄取(p<0.02),敏感性相似(92%)。每个视野使用3个节段时,该模型的特异性(93%)高于单独摄取(p<0.05)和定性分析(p<0.05),敏感性相似(85%)。(摘要截短于250字)