Hameed Malika, Akber Ali Naureen, Ahsan Khalid, Nazir Mohsin
Department of Anaesthesiology, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
Turk J Anaesthesiol Reanim. 2022 Aug;50(4):246-254. doi: 10.5152/TJAR.2021.20008.
Intraoperative shivering is quite common after regional anaesthesia, which not only increases the total body oxygen requirement but also causes discomfort to the patients. The aim of this systematic review is to determine the effectiveness of pharmacological agents administered intra-operatively for treating shivering in adult patients who are undergoing elective surgery under regional (i.e., central neuraxial) anaesthesia so that an optimal choice of an agent can be recommended for clinical application. A literature search was carried out using PubMed, Cochrane Library, CINAHL databases, and hand searches to identify relevant studies. After literature screening and information extraction, a systematic review was performed. Meta-analysis was performed for the primary outcome. The primary outcome was to evaluate the effectiveness of pharmacological agents used for the treatment and control of intraoperative shivering and the time taken to control shivering. The secondary outcome includes recurrence of shivering after pharmacological intervention and identification of common adverse effects related to them. In total, 10 studies (791 patients) were included. Common interventions were opioids, central α2 receptor agonist, and few other medications like magnesium sulfate, ondansetron, nefopam, and amitriptyline. Tramadol and dexmedetomidine were the most frequently documented drugs compared with other drugs to resolve shivering. The most effective drug with approximately 100% response rate was dexmedetomidine with the dose of 0.5 μg kg-1 intravenously given just after the appearance of shivering. Studies showed that tramadol is also an effective drug used to control shivering in most patients, and its effect is comparable with the pethidine.
区域麻醉后术中寒战相当常见,这不仅会增加全身的氧气需求,还会给患者带来不适。本系统评价的目的是确定术中给予药物治疗区域(即中枢神经轴)麻醉下接受择期手术的成年患者寒战的有效性,以便推荐最佳药物用于临床。使用PubMed、Cochrane图书馆、CINAHL数据库进行文献检索,并通过手工检索来识别相关研究。经过文献筛选和信息提取后,进行了系统评价。对主要结局进行荟萃分析。主要结局是评估用于治疗和控制术中寒战的药物的有效性以及控制寒战所需的时间。次要结局包括药物干预后寒战的复发以及识别与之相关的常见不良反应。总共纳入了10项研究(791例患者)。常见的干预措施有阿片类药物、中枢α2受体激动剂以及其他一些药物,如硫酸镁、昂丹司琼、奈福泮和阿米替林。与其他药物相比,曲马多和右美托咪定是记录最多的用于缓解寒战的药物。有效率约为100%的最有效药物是右美托咪定,在寒战出现后立即静脉注射剂量为0.5μg/kg。研究表明,曲马多也是大多数患者用于控制寒战的有效药物,其效果与哌替啶相当。