Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California.
VOICES Health Policy Research Center, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Stanford University, Redwood City, California.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023 Feb 1;105(3):e10. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.22.00353. Epub 2022 Aug 18.
Nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) from high-income countries provide surgical outreach for patients in low and middle-income countries (LMICs); however, these efforts lack a coordinated measurement of their ability to build capacity. While the World Health Organization and others recommend outreach trips that aim to build the capacity of the local health-care system, no guidance exists on how to accomplish this. The objective of this paper is to establish a framework and a blueprint to guide the operations of NGOs that provide outreach to build orthopaedic surgical capacity in LMICs.
We conducted a qualitative analysis of semistructured interviews with 16 orthopaedic surgeons and administrators located in 7 countries (6 LMICs) on the necessary domains for capacity-building; the analysis was guided by a literature review of capacity-building frameworks. We subsequently conducted a modified nominal group technique with a consortium of 10 U.S.-based surgeons with expertise in global surgical outreach, which was member-checked with 8 new stakeholders from 4 LMICs.
A framework with 7 domains for capacity-building in global surgical outreach was identified. The domains included professional development, finance, partnerships, governance, community impact, culture, and coordination. These domains were tiered in a hierarchical system to stratify the level of capacity for each domain. A blueprint was developed to guide the operations of an organization seeking to build capacity.
The developed framework identified 7 domains to address when building capacity during global orthopaedic surgical outreach. The framework and its tiered system can be used to assess capacity and guide capacity-building efforts in LMICs. The developed blueprint can inform the operations of NGOs toward activities that focus on building capacity in order to ensure a measured and sustained impact.
高收入国家的非政府组织(NGO)为中低收入国家(LMIC)的患者提供外科外展服务;然而,这些努力缺乏对其建立能力的能力进行协调衡量的手段。虽然世界卫生组织和其他组织建议开展旨在建立当地医疗保健系统能力的外展活动,但没有关于如何实现这一目标的指导。本文的目的是建立一个框架和蓝图,指导提供外展服务以在 LMIC 中建立骨科手术能力的 NGO 的运营。
我们对来自 7 个国家(6 个 LMIC)的 16 名骨科医生和管理人员进行了半结构化访谈,分析了建立能力所必需的领域;分析由对能力建设框架的文献回顾指导。随后,我们与来自 4 个 LMIC 的 8 名新利益相关者一起对由 10 名具有全球外展手术专业知识的美国外科医生组成的联盟进行了修改后的名义小组技术,该联盟成员由来自 4 个 LMIC 的 8 名新利益相关者进行了检查。
确定了全球外展外科能力建设的 7 个领域框架。这些领域包括专业发展、财务、伙伴关系、治理、社区影响、文化和协调。这些领域按照分层系统分层,以分层每个领域的能力水平。制定了蓝图来指导寻求建立能力的组织的运营。
所开发的框架确定了在全球骨科外展手术中建立能力时需要解决的 7 个领域。该框架及其分层系统可用于评估能力并指导 LMIC 中的能力建设工作。所开发的蓝图可以为 NGO 的运营提供信息,以开展专注于建立能力的活动,以确保有衡量和持续的影响。