Umberson Debra, Thomeer Mieke Beth, Pollitt Amanda M, Mernitz Sara E
University of Texas at Austin.
The University of Alabama at Birmingham.
J Marriage Fam. 2020 Aug;82(4):1141-1158. doi: 10.1111/jomf.12686. Epub 2020 May 11.
This study considers how the provision of daily emotion work may affect the psychological well-being of the emotion worker, and how this linkage may vary for men and women in same- and different-sex marriages.
Emotion work-work intended to bolster a spouse's well-being by reading and managing the spouse's emotional needs-is common within marital relationships and often gendered, with women more aware of and concerned with emotion work than men. Yet, the psychological cost of performing emotion work is largely unexplored.
This study relies on 10 days of daily experiences data from spouses in same- and different-sex marriages (n = 756 individuals). Mixed effects multilevel regression modeling is used to examine how the provision of emotion work is associated with the emotion workers' psychological well-being.
Providing emotion work is inversely associated with emotion workers' psychological well-being, especially when provided for a spouse with elevated depressive symptoms. These estimated effects are generally similar for men and women but greater for those married to a man than for those married to a woman, whether in a same- or different-sex marriage.
Emotion work appears to adversely affect the worker's own psychological well-being, especially when a spouse has elevated depressive symptoms and when one's spouse is a man. These results point to the importance of dyadic approaches and consideration of gendered relationship dynamics of same- as well as different-sex couples in studies of emotion work and other marital processes.
本研究探讨日常情感劳动的付出如何影响情感劳动者的心理健康,以及这种联系在同性婚姻和异性婚姻中的男性和女性之间会有怎样的差异。
情感劳动旨在通过解读和满足配偶的情感需求来增进配偶的幸福感,在婚姻关系中很常见,而且往往存在性别差异,女性比男性更了解并关注情感劳动。然而,进行情感劳动的心理成本在很大程度上尚未得到探讨。
本研究依赖于来自同性婚姻和异性婚姻配偶的10天日常经历数据(共756人)。采用混合效应多级回归模型来检验情感劳动的付出与情感劳动者心理健康之间的关联。
付出情感劳动与情感劳动者的心理健康呈负相关,尤其是为抑郁症状较重的配偶付出情感劳动时。这些估计效应在男性和女性中通常相似,但无论在同性婚姻还是异性婚姻中,与男性结婚者的效应比与女性结婚者更大。
情感劳动似乎会对劳动者自身的心理健康产生不利影响,尤其是当配偶抑郁症状较重且配偶为男性时。这些结果表明,在情感劳动和其他婚姻过程的研究中,采用二元方法以及考虑同性和异性伴侣的性别化关系动态具有重要意义。