De Gendt Erin E A, Schroeder Greg D, Joaquim Andrei, Tee Jin, Kanna Rishi M, Kandziora Frank, Dhakal Gaurav R, Vialle Emiliano N, El-Sharkawi Mohammad, Schnake Klaus J, Rajasekaran Shanmuganathan, Vaccaro Alex R, Muijs Sander P J, Benneker Lorin M, Oner F Cumhur
Department of Orthopedics, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rothman Institute, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA.
Clin Spine Surg. 2023 Mar 1;36(2):E94-E100. doi: 10.1097/BSD.0000000000001376. Epub 2022 Aug 22.
Survey among spine experts.
To investigate the different views and opinions of clinically relevant spinal post-traumatic deformity (SPTD).
There is no clear definition of clinically relevant SPTD. This leads to a wide variation in characteristics used for diagnosis and treatment indications of SPTD. To understand the current concepts of SPTD a survey was conducted among spine trauma surgeons.
Members of the AO Spine Knowledge Forum Trauma participated in an online survey. The survey was divided in 4 domains: Demographics, criteria to define SPTD, risk factors, and management. The data were collected anonymously and analyzed using descriptive statistics, absolute, and relative frequencies. Consensus on dichotomous outcomes was set to 80% of agreement.
Fifteen members with extensive experience in treatment of spinal trauma participated, representing the 5 AO Spine Regions. Back pain was the only criterion for definition of SPTD with complete agreement. Consensus (≥80%) was reached for kyphotic angulation outside normative ranges and impaired function. Eighty-seven percent and 100% agreed that a full-spine conventional radiograph was necessary in diagnosing and treating SPTD, respectively. The "missed B-type injury" was rated at most important by all but 1 participant. There was no agreement on other risk factors leading to clinically relevant SPTD. Concerning the management, all participants agreed that an asymptomatic patient should not undergo surgical treatment and that neurological deficit is an absolute surgical indication. For most of the participants the preferred surgical treatment of acute injury in all spine regions but the subaxial region is posterior fixation.
Some consensus exists among leading experts in the field of spine trauma care concerning the definition, diagnosis, risk factors, and management of SPTD. This study acts as the foundation for a Delphi study among the global spine community.
对脊柱专家进行调查。
调查临床上相关的脊柱创伤后畸形(SPTD)的不同观点和看法。
临床上相关的SPTD尚无明确的定义。这导致了用于SPTD诊断和治疗指征的特征存在很大差异。为了解SPTD的当前概念,对脊柱创伤外科医生进行了一项调查。
AO脊柱知识论坛创伤分会的成员参与了一项在线调查。该调查分为四个领域:人口统计学、定义SPTD的标准、危险因素和治疗。数据以匿名方式收集,并使用描述性统计、绝对频率和相对频率进行分析。二分法结果的共识设定为80%的一致性。
15名在脊柱创伤治疗方面有丰富经验的成员参与了调查,代表了AO脊柱的5个区域。背痛是定义SPTD的唯一标准,得到了完全一致的认可。对于超出正常范围的后凸成角和功能受损达成了共识(≥80%)。分别有87%和100%的人同意全脊柱传统X线片在诊断和治疗SPTD中是必要的。除1名参与者外,所有参与者都认为“漏诊的B型损伤”最为重要。对于导致临床上相关的SPTD的其他危险因素,未达成一致意见。关于治疗,所有参与者都同意无症状患者不应接受手术治疗,神经功能缺损是绝对的手术指征。对于大多数参与者来说,除下颈椎区域外,所有脊柱区域急性损伤的首选手术治疗方法是后路固定。
脊柱创伤治疗领域的主要专家在SPTD的定义、诊断、危险因素和治疗方面存在一些共识。本研究为全球脊柱学界的德尔菲研究奠定了基础。