Department of Civil Engineering, Najafabad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Najafabad 85141-43131, Iran.
Department of Civil Engineering, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan 81551-39998, Iran.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Aug 17;19(16):10209. doi: 10.3390/ijerph191610209.
In terms of safety management, the implementation of industrial parks construction projects (IPCPs) is incredibly challenging due to the special working conditions and the specific type of use of the buildings. On the other hand, the possibility of causing accidents in these areas based on human errors is high and important for project execution due to the risks of human errors and financial losses. Therefore, this study tries to fill this existing research gap by identifying and evaluating the effective key factors leading to the occurrence of construction accidents caused by human errors in the development of IPCPs. After a holistic review of the reported literature, four rounds of fuzzy Delphi survey were launched to capture the individual opinions and feedback from various project experts. Accordingly, 41 key factors affecting human errors in the implementation of industrial parks construction projects in Iran were identified and classified into nine main groups of wrong actions, observations/interpretations, planning/processes, equipment, organization, individual activities, environmental conditions, rescue, and technology. Then, the step-wise weight assessment ratio analysis (SWARA) method was adopted to rate and rank the identified factors of human errors in the implementation of IPCPs in Iran. The research findings indicated that among the elicited factors, time factor (0.1226), delayed interpretation (0.1080), and incorrect diagnosis/prediction (0.0990) are the three most crucial factors leading to human errors in the implementation of IPCPs in Iran. The results of this research study have provided various major project stakeholders with an effective decision-aid tool to make better-informed decisions in managing and reducing the occurrence of construction site accidents particularly caused by human errors associated with IPCPs.
在安全管理方面,由于工业园区建设项目(IPCP)的特殊工作条件和建筑物的特殊用途,其实施极具挑战性。另一方面,由于人为错误的风险和财务损失,这些区域发生事故的可能性很高,对项目执行也很重要。因此,本研究试图通过确定和评估导致人为错误导致 IPCP 开发中发生施工事故的有效关键因素来填补这一现有研究空白。在对报告文献进行全面回顾后,进行了四轮模糊德尔菲调查,以从各个项目专家那里获取个人意见和反馈。据此,确定并将影响伊朗工业园区建设项目实施中人为错误的 41 个关键因素分为九大类错误行为、观察/解释、规划/流程、设备、组织、个人活动、环境条件、救援和技术。然后,采用逐步权重评估比分析法(SWARA)对伊朗 IPCP 实施中人为错误的识别因素进行评分和排名。研究结果表明,在所引出的因素中,时间因素(0.1226)、延迟解释(0.1080)和错误诊断/预测(0.0990)是导致伊朗 IPCP 实施中人为错误的三个最关键因素。本研究结果为各种主要项目利益相关者提供了一个有效的决策辅助工具,以便在管理和减少施工现场事故,特别是与 IPCP 相关的人为错误导致的事故时做出更明智的决策。