Pérez-Neri Iván, Pineda Carlos, Flores-Guerrero Jose L, Estêvão M Dulce, Vasanthan Lenny T, Lorente Sonia, García-González Renato, Devulapalli Vighnesh, Weerasekara Ishanka, de Aguiar Débora Regina, Barros-Sevillano Shamir, Le Long Khanh-Dao, Sandoval Hugo
Department of Neurochemistry, National Institute of Neurology and Neurosurgery Manuel Velasco Suárez, Insurgentes Sur 3877; La Fama, Tlalpan., Ciudad de México, 14269, México.
General Directorate, National Institute of Rehabilitation Luis Guillermo Ibarra Ibarra, Calzada Mexico- Xochimilco 289; Arenal de Guadalupe, Ciudad de México, 14389, México.
Rheumatol Int. 2022 Dec;42(12):2135-2140. doi: 10.1007/s00296-022-05194-1. Epub 2022 Aug 27.
Literature searches are important components of systematic reviews. They are not only informative of the retrieval process, but they also set the data to be analyzed and influence additional components of systematic reviews. Despite the available guidelines, several studies have shown that the quality of reporting in systematic reviews is deficient in several medical fields. Systematic reviews may not comply completely with those guidelines despite explicitly stating they do. This protocol intends to answer to what extent systematic reviews published in rheumatology journals have complied with the PRISMA's search strategy guidelines published in 2009. The objective of the study is to analyze the compliance with the PRISMA (2009) search strategy guidelines among systematic reviews published in leading rheumatology journals. Inclusion criteria for this umbrella review protocol are systematic reviews (with or without meta-analyses) that mention having followed the PRISMA statement (2009) in their methods section, and published in journals listed in the Rheumatology category of the Journal of Citations Report 2020. Exclusion criteria are articles published before 2009; retraction letters, notes, expressions of concern; systematic reviews using PRISMA 2020. Databases to be consulted are Web of Science, PubMed and Scopus, from inception to present. Data summaries will be presented in graphs, figures, tables and network maps. A narrative synthesis will be described. This protocol complies with guidelines such as PRISMA 2020, PRISMA-A, PRISMA-P, PRISMA-S, PRESS, and JBI Manual for evidence synthesis, as long as it is suitable for umbrella review protocols. Articles in any language will be considered.
文献检索是系统评价的重要组成部分。它们不仅能提供检索过程的信息，还能确定要分析的数据，并影响系统评价的其他组成部分。尽管有可用的指南，但多项研究表明，在几个医学领域，系统评价的报告质量存在缺陷。系统评价可能并未完全遵守这些指南，尽管它们明确表示遵守了。本方案旨在回答发表在风湿病学杂志上的系统评价在多大程度上符合2009年发布的PRISMA检索策略指南。该研究的目的是分析发表在主要风湿病学杂志上的系统评价对PRISMA（2009）检索策略指南的遵守情况。本综合评价方案的纳入标准是在方法部分提及遵循PRISMA声明（2009）的系统评价（无论是否有荟萃分析），并发表在《2020年期刊引证报告》风湿病学类别所列的期刊上。排除标准是2009年之前发表的文章；撤稿信、注释、关注声明；使用PRISMA 2020的系统评价。将检索的数据库是Web of Science、PubMed和Scopus，从创建至今。数据总结将以图表、图形、表格和网络图的形式呈现。将进行叙述性综合。本方案符合PRISMA 2020、PRISMA-A、PRISMA-P、PRISMA-S、PRESS和JBI证据综合手册等指南，只要适用于综合评价方案即可。将考虑任何语言的文章。
