Henstenburg Jeffrey M, Abdelfadeel Walaa, Boniello Anthony J, Schmitz Joseph, Vakil Jeffrey J, Star Andrew M
Rothman Orthopaedic Institute, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Drexel University College of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Arch Bone Jt Surg. 2022 Jul;10(7):561-567. doi: 10.22038/ABJS.2021.53669.2669.
Orthopaedic surgeons rely on visual and tactile cues to guide performance in the operating room (OR). However, there is very little data on how sound changes during orthopaedic procedures and how surgeons incorporate audio feedback to guide performance. This study attempts to define meaningful changes in sound during vital aspects of total hip arthroplasty (THA) within the spectrum of human hearing.
84 audio recordings were obtained during primary elective THA procedures during sawing of the femoral neck, reaming of the acetabulum, acetabular cup impaction, polyethylene liner impaction, femoral broaching, planning of the femoral calcar and press-fit of a porous-coated stem in 14 patients. We graphed changes in frequency intensity across the human spectrum of hearing and sampled frequencies showing differences over time for statistically meaningful changes.
Sawing of the femoral neck, polyethylene impaction, and stem insertion showed significant temporal increases in overall sound intensity. Calcar planing showed a significant decrease in sound intensity. Moreover, spectrographic analysis showed that, for each of the critical tasks in THA, there were characteristic frequencies that showed maximal changes in loudness. These changes were above the 1 dB change in intensity required for detection by the human ear.
Our results clearly demonstrate reproducible sound changes during total hip arthroplasty that are detectable by the human ear. Surgeons can incorporate sound as a valuable source of feedback while performing total hip arthroplasty to guide optimal performance in the OR. These findings can be extrapolated to other orthopaedic procedures that produce characteristic changes in sound. Moreover, it emphasizes the importance of limiting ambient noise in the OR that might make sound changes hard to distinguish.
骨科医生依靠视觉和触觉线索来指导手术室(OR)中的操作。然而,关于骨科手术过程中声音如何变化以及外科医生如何利用音频反馈来指导操作的数据非常少。本研究试图确定在人类听力范围内全髋关节置换术(THA)关键环节中声音的有意义变化。
在14例患者的初次择期THA手术中,获取了84段音频记录,记录内容包括股骨颈锯切、髋臼扩孔、髋臼杯打压、聚乙烯内衬打压、股骨扩髓、股骨距规划以及多孔涂层柄的压配过程。我们绘制了人类听力范围内频率强度的变化图,并对随时间显示出差异的频率进行采样,以找出具有统计学意义的变化。
股骨颈锯切、聚乙烯内衬打压和柄插入过程中,总体声音强度随时间显著增加。股骨距规划时声音强度显著降低。此外,频谱分析表明,对于THA中的每个关键任务,都有特征频率在响度上显示出最大变化。这些变化超过了人耳可检测到的强度变化1dB。
我们的结果清楚地表明,全髋关节置换术中存在可被人耳检测到的可重复声音变化。外科医生在进行全髋关节置换术时可将声音作为有价值的反馈来源,以指导手术室中的最佳操作。这些发现可外推至其他会产生特征性声音变化的骨科手术。此外,这强调了限制手术室环境噪声的重要性,因为环境噪声可能会使声音变化难以区分。