Modelling and Simulation Group, Department of Computer Science, Brunel University London, Uxbridge, London, United Kingdom.
Global Public Health, Department of Health Sciences, Brunel University London, Uxbridge, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2022 Aug 29;17(8):e0272664. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0272664. eCollection 2022.
We present our agent-based CoronAvirus Lifelong Modelling and Simulation (CALMS) model that aspires to predict the lifelong impacts of Covid-19 on the health and economy of a population. CALMS considers individual characteristics as well as comorbidities in calculating the risk of infection and severe disease. We conduct two sets of experiments aiming at demonstrating the validity and capabilities of CALMS. We run simulations retrospectively and validate the model outputs against hospitalisations, ICU admissions and fatalities in a UK population for the period between March and September 2020. We then run simulations for the lifetime of the cohort applying a variety of targeted intervention strategies and compare their effectiveness against the baseline scenario where no intervention is applied. Four scenarios are simulated with targeted vaccination programmes and periodic lockdowns. Vaccinations are targeted first at individuals based on their age and second at vulnerable individuals based on their health status. Periodic lockdowns, triggered by hospitalisations, are tested with and without vaccination programme in place. Our results demonstrate that periodic lockdowns achieve reductions in hospitalisations, ICU admissions and fatalities of 6-8% compared to the baseline scenario, with an associated intervention cost of £173 million per 1,000 people and targeted vaccination programmes achieve reductions in hospitalisations, ICU admissions and fatalities of 89-90%, compared to the baseline scenario, with an associated intervention cost of £51,924 per 1,000 people. We conclude that periodic lockdowns alone are ineffective at reducing health-related outputs over the long-term and that vaccination programmes which target only the clinically vulnerable are sufficient in providing healthcare protection for the population as a whole.
我们提出了基于代理的 CoronAvirus 终身建模和模拟 (CALMS) 模型,旨在预测 COVID-19 对人群健康和经济的终身影响。CALMS 在计算感染和严重疾病风险时考虑了个体特征和合并症。我们进行了两组实验,旨在展示 CALMS 的有效性和功能。我们进行了回顾性模拟,并将模型输出与 2020 年 3 月至 9 月期间英国人口的住院、重症监护病房入院和死亡进行了验证。然后,我们对队列的一生进行了模拟,应用了各种针对性的干预策略,并将其效果与未应用干预的基线情景进行了比较。模拟了四种针对特定疫苗接种计划和定期封锁的情况。疫苗接种首先针对基于年龄的个体,其次针对基于健康状况的脆弱个体。在不实施疫苗接种计划的情况下,对定期封锁(通过住院触发)进行了测试。我们的结果表明,与基线情景相比,定期封锁可将住院、重症监护病房入院和死亡人数减少 6-8%,干预成本为每 1000 人 1.73 亿英镑,有针对性的疫苗接种计划可将住院、重症监护病房入院和死亡人数减少 89-90%,与基线情景相比,干预成本为每 1000 人 51,924 英镑。我们的结论是,单独的定期封锁在长期内无法有效降低与健康相关的产出,并且仅针对临床脆弱人群的疫苗接种计划足以提供整个人群的医疗保健保护。