Ali N, Saunders J, Ibbotson R, Shute E, Burke G, Cadman V, Elkington M, Nightingale J
Sheffield Hallam University, Dept of Allied Health Professions, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
Sheffield Hallam University, College of Health, Wellbeing and Life Sciences, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
Radiography (Lond). 2022 Oct;28 Suppl 1:S77-S83. doi: 10.1016/j.radi.2022.08.001. Epub 2022 Aug 27.
Clinical visits (work experience opportunities) are a recommended part of admissions processes for many diagnostic and therapeutic radiography courses but not for operating department practice (ODP) where observational visits are challenging for applicants to obtain. The Covid-19 pandemic interrupted access to visits for all prospective students; this study presents a review of the value of clinical visits and alternatives.
This article reports the initial qualitative phase of a three-phase mixed methods study. Using a critical realist approach, focus groups explored first year student experiences of the 'ideal' pre-admission clinical visit and alternative resources. A structured review of Online Prospectus (OLP) entries was undertaken by two student researchers to ascertain the requirements for clinical visits for the three professions.
Four focus groups included 25 first year students interviewed prior to their first clinical placement (14 therapeutic radiography, 5 diagnostic radiography and 6 ODP students). Three themes were constructed, namely: informing career choices, the clinical visit experience, and the value of clinical visits. Clinical visits affirmed rather than inspired career choices. The best timing for a visit was before admission interviews and optimal duration was a full day. Interacting with current students was the most valued aspect. Videos and simulations provided in-depth information about the professional role and allowed replay, but some participants found the videos uninspiring. OLP entries present a confusing picture for applicants who may be researching several Universities and professions.
Clinical visits were deemed 'vital' to radiography student career choices, yet ODPs who could not access visits were comfortable with videos. Simulated visits are a safe option amidst the pandemic but must capture the dynamic and patient-centred nature of practice to accurately inform career choices.
临床见习(工作经验机会)是许多诊断和治疗放射学课程录取过程中的推荐环节,但手术室实践(ODP)课程并非如此,申请者很难获得观摩见习的机会。新冠疫情中断了所有准学生的见习机会;本研究对临床见习的价值及替代方式进行了综述。
本文报告了一项三阶段混合方法研究的初始定性阶段。采用批判实在论方法,焦点小组探讨了一年级学生对“理想”的入学前临床见习及替代资源的体验。两名学生研究人员对在线招生简章(OLP)条目进行了结构化审查,以确定这三个专业对临床见习的要求。
四个焦点小组包括25名一年级学生,他们在首次临床实习前接受了访谈(14名治疗放射学专业学生、5名诊断放射学专业学生和6名ODP专业学生)。构建了三个主题,即:为职业选择提供信息、临床见习体验以及临床见习的价值。临床见习证实而非激发了职业选择。最佳见习时间是在入学面试之前,最佳时长为一整天。与在校学生互动是最有价值的方面。视频和模拟提供了有关专业角色的深入信息并可回放,但一些参与者认为这些视频缺乏吸引力。对于可能在研究多所大学和多个专业的申请者来说,OLP条目呈现出一幅令人困惑的画面。
临床见习被认为对放射学专业学生的职业选择“至关重要”,然而无法参加见习的ODP专业学生对视频感到满意。在疫情期间,模拟见习是一种安全的选择,但必须体现实践的动态性和以患者为中心的特点,才能准确地为职业选择提供信息。