Department of Medical Education, College of Medicine, Hawler Medical University, Erbil, Iraq.
Department of Community Medicine, College of Medicine, Hawler Medical University, Erbil, Iraq.
PLoS One. 2022 Sep 2;17(9):e0274055. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0274055. eCollection 2022.
Objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) has been used in evaluating clinical competence in health professions education around the world. Despite its implementation in Iraq for around a decade, limited studies investigated the challenges and opportunities to improve the standard and quality of this examination from student's perspective.
This qualitative study was based on an online open-ended questionnaire survey that was carried out in the College of Medicine, Hawler Medical University, Iraq at the beginning of the 2018-2019 academic year. A convenience sample of 180 students in the clinical phase (4th, 5th, and 6th) year of study were invited to participate.
A total of 141 students responded to the online questionnaire. The participants were generally happy with the OSCE, and they recognized many positive aspects, including the role of the OSCE in increasing confidence, engagement and motivating learning, the role of the OSCE in achieving a higher level of learning, the content validity of the OSCE, and the quality of the OSCE. The main weak points of the OSCE identified by the students included unfairness, gender discrimination, duration of the OSCE, and the behavior of the examiners. Suggestions to improve the OSCE examination included improving the examiners' behavior, with the focus on the training of the examiners, and avoiding discrimination among students.
Most of the students were generally satisfied with the current OSCE examination. The main concern of the students was related to the organization of the OSCE. Valuable suggestions were raised to improve the OSCE quality including examiners' and simulated patients' training.
客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)已在全球范围内用于评估健康专业教育中的临床能力。尽管在伊拉克实施了大约十年,但从学生的角度来看,有限的研究调查了改善该考试的标准和质量的挑战和机遇。
本定性研究基于在伊拉克 Hawler 医科大学医学院进行的在线开放式问卷调查,该调查于 2018-2019 学年开始。邀请了 180 名处于临床阶段(第 4、5 和 6 年)的学生参加便利抽样。
共有 141 名学生对在线问卷做出了回应。参与者普遍对 OSCE 感到满意,他们认识到许多积极方面,包括 OSCE 在增强信心、参与和激励学习方面的作用、OSCE 在达到更高学习水平方面的作用、OSCE 的内容有效性以及 OSCE 的质量。学生确定的 OSCE 的主要弱点包括不公平、性别歧视、OSCE 的持续时间以及考官的行为。改善 OSCE 考试的建议包括改善考官的行为,重点是考官的培训,并避免学生之间的歧视。
大多数学生对当前的 OSCE 考试总体上感到满意。学生最关心的是 OSCE 的组织。提出了有价值的建议来提高 OSCE 质量,包括考官和模拟患者的培训。