Kellehear Allan, Garrido Matilda
University of Vermont, USA.
University of Vermont, USA.
Arch Gerontol Geriatr. 2023 Jan;104:104798. doi: 10.1016/j.archger.2022.104798. Epub 2022 Aug 31.
After significant early interest in aging and dying, recent empirical studies have been few and theoretically fragmented.
The aims of this review were to map what is empirically known about the intersections between existential aging (a sense of passing years that evoke a sense of nearness-to-death) and dying identity and to describe the available evidence.
Articles were reviewed employing PRISMA guidelines. Seven data bases were searched resulted in 165 records. Of these 165 records a final selection of 24 studies that met the criteria were examined.
Evidence from the review found that the formation of the identity of dying alongside existential aging was associated with personal changes related to self/gerotranscendence, self-concerns about the inevitability of death (mortality salience), self-concerns about the prospect of death (death anxiety), attitudes toward the older self as a moderator of attitudes to death (aging attitudes), or simply anticipating the death of self (the future). Collectively, these studies found that death and dying were threats or challenges to life as an increasingly aging identity and that this seems to require compensation or accommodation.
These studies confirm the importance of nearness-to-death on identity formation and psychological change in older populations. However, most of the studies were quantitative and tested for pre-existing ideas and concepts. There is a need for more qualitative studies to search for wider or parallel meanings about identity change in the face of aging and death, more longitudinal designs, and greater attention to mixed methods approaches, especially for populations for whom talk or writing may be restrictive.
在早期对衰老和死亡产生显著兴趣之后,近期的实证研究较少且在理论上较为零散。
本综述的目的是梳理关于存在性衰老(一种岁月流逝引发濒死感的感觉)与死亡身份认同之间交叉点的实证所知,并描述现有证据。
采用PRISMA指南对文章进行综述。搜索了七个数据库,得到165条记录。在这165条记录中,最终筛选出24项符合标准的研究进行审查。
综述证据发现,随着存在性衰老,死亡身份认同的形成与自我/老年超越、对死亡必然性的自我关注(死亡凸显)、对死亡前景的自我关注(死亡焦虑)、将老年自我视为死亡态度调节因素的态度(衰老态度)或仅仅是对自我死亡的预期(未来)等个人变化相关。总体而言,这些研究发现,死亡和濒死对作为日益衰老身份的生命构成威胁或挑战,而这似乎需要补偿或调适。
这些研究证实了濒死对老年人群身份形成和心理变化的重要性。然而,大多数研究是定量的,且对预先存在的观念和概念进行了测试。需要更多定性研究来探寻面对衰老和死亡时身份变化的更广泛或平行的意义,更多纵向设计,并更关注混合方法,尤其是对于那些谈话或写作可能受限的人群。