Copeland L, Wolraich M, Lindgren S, Milich R, Woolson R
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1987 Aug;8(4):191-7.
This study examined, in a national survey, the assessment and treatment practices of pediatricians who care for children with attention deficit disorders (ADD). A questionnaire was sent to randomly selected members of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), stratified by state. Of 417 (52%) responses returned, there were 290 (38%) completed questionnaires. It was found that most pediatricians did not utilize specific DSM-III criteria for ADD; however, they do rely on symptoms of distractibility, overactivity, and impulsivity, which are the behaviors central to the DSM-III diagnosis. In addition, learning difficulties were felt to be contributory. Parents were the most frequently reported sources of information about a child's behavior, but the histories provided by teachers, and psychoeducational reports, also were sought frequently. Many pediatricians still use diagnostic procedures that have recently come under question, such as soft neurologic signs, activity level in the office, and response to stimulant medication. Methylphenidate and behavior modification were the most frequent therapies employed. Over half of the respondents use periodic reevaluation with rating scales to determine medication efficacy, but very few use placebo trials. More recently trained pediatricians tended to rely more on behavioral treatments than did earlier trained physicians.
本研究在一项全国性调查中,考察了照料患有注意力缺陷障碍(ADD)儿童的儿科医生的评估和治疗方法。向美国儿科学会(AAP)随机抽取的成员发放了调查问卷,并按州进行分层。在回收的417份(52%)问卷中,有290份(38%)是完整问卷。结果发现,大多数儿科医生并未采用《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版(DSM - III)中关于ADD的具体标准;然而,他们确实依赖注意力分散、多动和冲动等症状,这些是DSM - III诊断的核心行为。此外,人们认为学习困难也有影响。父母是关于儿童行为最常被提及的信息来源,但教师提供的病史以及心理教育报告也经常被寻求。许多儿科医生仍在使用最近受到质疑的诊断程序,如软神经体征、诊室中的活动水平以及对兴奋剂药物的反应。哌甲酯和行为矫正疗法是最常采用的治疗方法。超过一半的受访者使用评分量表定期重新评估以确定药物疗效,但很少有人进行安慰剂试验。与早期接受培训的医生相比,近期接受培训的儿科医生往往更依赖行为治疗。