Ellis R, Kelsay J L, Reynolds R D, Morris E R, Moser P B, Frazier C W
J Am Diet Assoc. 1987 Aug;87(8):1043-7.
The literature indicates that phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios of a diet may provide useful indexes of the bioavailability of dietary zinc. However, there is little information on the phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios for total human diets. We have therefore determined the phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios of self-selected diets of 29 American omnivores, 23 American vegetarians, 30 Asian Indian immigrant vegetarians, and 26 Nepalese lactating vegetarians. Criteria for selection of subjects were: good health, no extreme dietary habits, and no intake of nutrient supplements. According to the limited literature, the suggested critical values for phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios in animal diets and retrospective calculations from human diets are greater than 10 and greater than 200, respectively. The mean phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios of American omnivorous diets in the present study were less than 10 and 200, respectively. Confirmation of the critical molar ratios as indexes of the bioavailability of zinc in human diets has not been established by experimentation. However, if the data from animal studies are applicable to human diets, the present study suggests that phytate has little influence on zinc bioavailability of most American diets. In contrast, the mean phytate:zinc and phytate X calcium:zinc millimolar ratios of all vegetarian diets were above the proposed critical levels. Those data, therefore, suggest that phytate might increase the risk of impaired zinc bioavailability for vegetarians consuming a relatively high level of calcium.
文献表明,饮食中植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比可能为膳食锌的生物利用率提供有用指标。然而,关于人类总体饮食中植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比的信息却很少。因此,我们测定了29名美国杂食者、23名美国素食者、30名亚洲印度移民素食者和26名尼泊尔哺乳期素食者自行选择的饮食中植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比。选择受试者的标准为:身体健康、无极端饮食习惯且不摄入营养补充剂。根据有限的文献,动物饮食中植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及根据人类饮食进行回顾性计算得出的植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比的建议临界值分别大于10和大于200。在本研究中,美国杂食性饮食的植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比的平均值分别小于10和200。尚未通过实验确定这些临界摩尔比作为人类饮食中锌生物利用率指标的有效性。然而,如果动物研究的数据适用于人类饮食,那么本研究表明植酸盐对大多数美国饮食中锌的生物利用率影响很小。相比之下,所有素食饮食的植酸盐与锌的摩尔比以及植酸盐与钙的乘积与锌的摩尔比的平均值均高于建议的临界水平。因此,这些数据表明,对于摄入相对高水平钙的素食者而言,植酸盐可能会增加锌生物利用率受损的风险。