Cleeves L, Findley L J
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1987 Jun;50(6):704-8. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.50.6.704.
Tremor amplitude was monitored in untreated patients with essential tremor by a procedure designed to minimise fluctuations due to factors known to influence tremor. Tremor was measured hourly for 6 hours in 14 patients and on five to seven occasions (separated by at least a week) in 22 patients. A wide range of within-patient variability was found, with some patients showing little and others showing considerable fluctuations in amplitude over the series of recordings. There was no simple relationship between variability and mean amplitude, frequency, age, duration of tremor or response to a single oral dose of propranolol. Variability did not differ between males and females or between patients with and without a family history of tremor. Diurnal fluctuations showed no consistent pattern. Long-term assessment revealed a significant trend towards lower amplitudes on successive occasions. To overcome systematic bias in data collection, clinical trials in essential tremor should employ large numbers of patients and rigorous randomisation of treatments in cross-over designs.
通过一种旨在将已知影响震颤的因素所导致的波动降至最低的程序,对未经治疗的特发性震颤患者的震颤幅度进行监测。14名患者每小时测量一次震颤,持续6小时;22名患者在五到七次(每次间隔至少一周)测量震颤。发现患者内部存在广泛的变异性,在一系列记录中,一些患者的震颤幅度波动很小,而另一些患者则波动很大。变异性与平均幅度、频率、年龄、震颤持续时间或单次口服普萘洛尔的反应之间没有简单的关系。男性和女性之间以及有和没有震颤家族史的患者之间的变异性没有差异。昼夜波动没有一致的模式。长期评估显示,连续测量时幅度有显著降低的趋势。为了克服数据收集过程中的系统偏差,特发性震颤的临床试验应采用大量患者,并在交叉设计中对治疗进行严格随机化。