Lanza L A, Miser J S, Pass H I, Roth J A
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1987 Aug;94(2):181-7.
We have investigated the role of resection in the treatment of patients with isolated pulmonary metastases from Ewing's sarcoma. In a retrospective review, 19 patients with the diagnosis of Ewing's sarcoma treated at the National Cancer Institute from 1965 to 1985 who underwent chest exploration for resection of pulmonary nodules were evaluated. Ten patients (53%) were made disease free by resection of pulmonary metastases, six patients (32%) were found to have unresectable disease, and three patients (16%) were found to have benign pulmonary disease. The actuarial 5 year survival rate of the 10 patients successfully made disease free by resection was 15%, and the median survival of this group was 28 months. In contrast, the median survival of the six patients not made disease free was 12 months, and no patient with residual disease was alive 22 months after thoracotomy (p2 = 0.0047). There were no postoperative deaths and only three minor postoperative complications for 25 operative procedures. Various prognostic variables were analyzed to determine their influence on postmetastasectomy survival. There was no difference in postmetastasectomy survival between patients who underwent resection of synchronous versus metachronous pulmonary metastases (p2 = 0.90). Patients who underwent resection of fewer than four malignant nodules had a significantly longer postmetastasectomy disease-free survival (p2 = 0.0019) and overall survival (p2 = 0.06) than those undergoing resection of four or more nodules. Patients who underwent resection of metastases that developed during chemotherapy had a significantly shorter postmetastasectomy survival that those who underwent resection of metastases that developed after chemotherapy (p2 = 0.0295). Our data show that selected patients with Ewing's sarcoma metastatic to the lungs may benefit from an aggressive surgical approach. Also, a significant proportion of these patients will have benign pulmonary disease and can thus avoid additional intensive systemic therapy.
我们研究了手术切除在尤因肉瘤孤立性肺转移患者治疗中的作用。在一项回顾性研究中,对1965年至1985年在国立癌症研究所接受治疗、因切除肺结节而进行胸部探查的19例尤因肉瘤患者进行了评估。10例患者(53%)通过切除肺转移灶实现了无病生存,6例患者(32%)被发现存在无法切除的疾病,3例患者(16%)被发现患有良性肺部疾病。通过手术切除成功实现无病生存的10例患者的5年精算生存率为15%,该组患者的中位生存期为28个月。相比之下,6例未实现无病生存的患者的中位生存期为12个月,开胸术后22个月时,无残留疾病的患者无一存活(p2 = 0.0047)。25例手术均无术后死亡,仅出现3例轻微术后并发症。分析了各种预后变量,以确定它们对转移灶切除术后生存的影响。同期与异时性肺转移灶切除患者的转移灶切除术后生存无差异(p2 = 0.90)。切除少于4个恶性结节的患者,其转移灶切除术后无病生存期(p2 = 0.0019)和总生存期(p2 = 0.06)明显长于切除4个或更多结节的患者。化疗期间出现转移灶而接受切除的患者,其转移灶切除术后生存期明显短于化疗后出现转移灶而接受切除的患者(p2 = 0.0295)。我们的数据表明,部分尤因肉瘤肺转移患者可能从积极的手术治疗中获益。此外,这些患者中有相当一部分患有良性肺部疾病,因此可避免额外的强化全身治疗。