Department of Biochemistry, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen, People's Republic of China.
Department of Statistics and Data Science, College of Science, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen, People's Republic of China.
Mol Biol Cell. 2022 Oct 1;33(12). doi: 10.1091/mbc.E22-04-0140.
Although the process of publishing a scientific paper has gotten simpler, it is increasingly difficult to publish a paper in high profile journals. We have analyzed the publishing data in the cell biology field and found several alarming trends developing over the last two decades. There is an emerging divide between scientist-run journals and professional-run high profile journals. How did this happen? What should we do? The core issue is whether the current standard for high profile journals hurts rather than helps the scientific discovery process. In this regard, we suggest that the editors and scientists should direct their focus on the potential impact and rigor of the work instead of the "perfection" or "completeness" of the study.
尽管发表科学论文的过程变得更加简单,但在高影响力期刊上发表论文却越来越困难。我们分析了细胞生物学领域的发表数据,发现过去二十年来出现了一些令人担忧的趋势。科学家运营的期刊和专业运营的高影响力期刊之间出现了明显的分化。这是怎么发生的?我们应该怎么做?核心问题是当前高影响力期刊的标准是促进还是阻碍了科学发现过程。在这方面,我们建议编辑和科学家应该关注工作的潜在影响和严谨性,而不是研究的“完美”或“完整性”。