Sound Perception and Design group, STMS, IRCAM, Sorbonne Université, CNRS, Ministère de la Culture, 75004 Paris, France
JASA Express Lett. 2022 Jun;2(6):064404. doi: 10.1121/10.0011752.
When designing sound evaluation experiments, researchers rely on listening test methods, such as rating scales (RS). This work aims to investigate the suitability of best-worst scaling (BWS) for the perceptual evaluation of sound qualities. To do so, 20 participants rated the "brightness" of a corpus of instrumental sounds (N = 100) with RS and BWS methods. The results show that BWS procedure is the fastest and that RS and BWS are equivalent in terms of performance. Interestingly, participants preferred BWS over RS. Therefore, BWS is an alternative method that reliably measures perceptual sound qualities and could be used in many-sounds paradigm.
在设计声音评估实验时,研究人员依赖于听力测试方法,例如评分量表 (RS)。本工作旨在研究最佳最差标度 (BWS) 用于声音质量感知评估的适用性。为此,20 名参与者使用 RS 和 BWS 方法对一组乐器声音的“亮度”进行了评分(N=100)。结果表明,BWS 程序最快,并且在性能方面 RS 和 BWS 是等效的。有趣的是,参与者更喜欢 BWS 而不是 RS。因此,BWS 是一种可靠测量感知声音质量的替代方法,可用于多声音范式。