Koppers David, Van Henricus L, Peen Jaap, Dekker Jack J M
Research Department INFORSA/ARKIN.
NPI Centre for Personality Disorders, Arkin Mental Healthcare Institute.
Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2023 Jan 1;36(1):80-85. doi: 10.1097/YCO.0000000000000828. Epub 2022 Sep 27.
To provide an update of outcome studies of schema group therapy for personality disorders and the effect of comorbidity in order to explore whether schema group therapy might be effective for this patient group and what dosage is required.
Studies of short-term schema group therapy for personality disorders with or without comorbidity show moderately effective results but the majority of patients fail to achieve full remission from global psychological symptom distress. Preliminary findings revealed that those unremitted patients might benefit from 40 to 60 sessions. Patients with severe personality disorders (such as borderline personality disorders) seem to need longer and/or more intensive treatment dosage to recover.
We advocate short-term schema therapy in groups as a valuable first step in a stepped-care programme for patients with moderate personality disorders and comorbidity.Treatment extension or treatment intensification may be indicated in patients who do not recover. Patients with severe personality disorders seem to require long-term outpatient group treatment, with a combination of group and individual treatment being preferable. High-quality randomized controlled trials are needed in order to determine which treatment dosage is necessary for whom.
提供关于人格障碍图式团体治疗的疗效研究及共病影响的最新情况,以探讨图式团体治疗对该患者群体是否有效以及需要何种剂量。
针对伴有或不伴有共病的人格障碍进行短期图式团体治疗的研究显示出中等程度的有效结果,但大多数患者未能从整体心理症状困扰中完全缓解。初步研究结果表明,那些未缓解的患者可能从40至60次治疗中获益。患有严重人格障碍(如边缘型人格障碍)的患者似乎需要更长时间和/或更密集的治疗剂量才能康复。
我们提倡将团体短期图式治疗作为中度人格障碍及共病患者分级护理计划中有价值的第一步。对于未康复的患者,可能需要延长治疗或强化治疗。患有严重人格障碍的患者似乎需要长期门诊团体治疗,团体治疗与个体治疗相结合可能更为可取。需要高质量的随机对照试验来确定对谁需要何种治疗剂量。