Avezum Marina Dias Macedo de Melo, Altafim Elisa Rachel Pisani, Linhares Maria Beatriz Martins
University of São Paulo, Ribeirão Preto, Brazil.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2023 Dec;24(5):3094-3111. doi: 10.1177/15248380221124243. Epub 2022 Sep 30.
Violence against children is a significant problem, particularly during early childhood development. Spanking and other forms of corporal punishment in child-rearing have been used by families worldwide to correct children's unwanted behaviors. Despite previous studies focusing on the negative consequences of these parental practices, open questions remain. The present study aimed to systematically review the empirical studies published in scientific literature that examined the associations between parenting practices of spanking and corporal punishment of mothers and their children's behaviors and development in early childhood. Search was performed in PubMed, APA PsycNet, Web of Science, SciELO, and LILACS databases using the combination of the following keywords: ((spank OR physical punishment OR physical abuse OR physical maltreatment OR corporal punishment) AND (parenting)) AND (child* development OR child* behavior). The inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied and 34 articles were selected for review. The inclusion criteria were the following: studies that evaluated associations between maternal spanking or corporal punishment practices and behaviors or development of 0-to-6-year-old children; quantitative studies; studies published in English, Spanish, or Portuguese language. The results showed that in 94% of the studies, there were significant associations between maternal spanking and corporal punishment with deteriorated child behavior and development, concurrently or later. In addition, maternal physical practices also acted as mediators or moderator variables in models that explained behavioral and developmental problems in early childhood.
暴力侵害儿童是一个重大问题,尤其是在儿童早期发展阶段。在全球范围内,家庭在育儿过程中使用打屁股和其他形式的体罚来纠正孩子不良行为。尽管以往的研究关注这些育儿方式的负面后果,但仍存在一些未解决的问题。本研究旨在系统回顾科学文献中发表的实证研究,这些研究考察了母亲打屁股和体罚的育儿方式与孩子在幼儿期的行为及发展之间的关联。使用以下关键词组合在PubMed、APA PsycNet、Web of Science、SciELO和LILACS数据库中进行检索:((打屁股或身体惩罚或身体虐待或身体虐待或体罚)且(育儿))且(儿童发展或儿童行为)。应用纳入和排除标准,选择了34篇文章进行综述。纳入标准如下:评估母亲打屁股或体罚行为与0至6岁儿童行为或发展之间关联的研究;定量研究;以英语、西班牙语或葡萄牙语发表的研究。结果表明,在94%的研究中,母亲打屁股和体罚与儿童行为和发展恶化之间存在显著关联,无论是同时还是之后。此外,母亲的体罚行为在解释幼儿行为和发展问题的模型中也充当调节变量或中介变量。