Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shamir (Assaf Harofeh) Medical Center, Zerifin, Israel.
PreTwin Screen Consortium and TeleMarpe Ltd, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023 May;61(5):610-616. doi: 10.1002/uog.26093. Epub 2023 Apr 7.
To compare the prevalence of preterm birth (PTB) (delivery before 37 weeks) in Israel before and after publication of national guidelines recommending second-trimester sonographic cervical-length (CL) measurement.
The Israeli Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology (ISOG) guidelines, issued on 1 January 2012, specified that CL should be measured transabdominally or, if this is not possible, transvaginally, at the 19-25-week ultrasound anomaly scan and that CL < 25 mm should indicate further work-up and treatment, although the type of treatment was unspecified. In 2000, the Israel Ministry of Health issued a legal requirement for the submission of delivery records to a national registry. These data were used to compare PTB prevalence in the period before (2000-2011) and that after (2012-2020) publication of the guidelines, as well as trends within each time period. Information was available on singleton and multiple pregnancy and maternal age and parity, as well as low birth weight (< 2500 g).
During the period 2000-2020, there were 3 403 976 infants liveborn in Israel: 1 797 657 before and 1 606 319 after publication of the ISOG guidelines. There were 247 187 PTBs overall, with a prevalence of 7.64% (95% CI, 7.52-7.77%) before publication of the guidelines and 6.84% (95% CI, 6.43-7.24%) afterwards (P < 0.0002, two-tailed). The annual PTB prevalence was static in the first time period but declined by 0.18% per annum during the second period, after publication of the guidelines. The proportionate reduction in PTB prevalence after compared with before publication of the guidelines was 10% overall, 9% for PTB at 33-36 weeks, 18% for PTB at 28-32 weeks and 24% for PTB at < 28 weeks. After publication of the guidelines, reduced prevalence of PTB was observed among singletons (5.49% before vs 4.83% after, P < 0.0001), but not among infants in twin or higher-order multiple pregnancy. There was a statistically significant reduction in the rate of PTB following publication of the guidelines in both nulliparous and parous women and in the 19-39-year-old maternal-age group. Although reductions in PTB prevalence were also noted in high-risk age groups (maternal age < 19 years and ≥ 40 years), these did not reach statistical significance. Following publication of the guidelines, there was a statistically significant reduction in the prevalence of birth weight under 2500 g, of a magnitude similar to that for PTB prevalence.
The publication of national guidelines recommending routine CL measurement at the time of the second-trimester anomaly scan was associated with a fall in PTB prevalence in singleton pregnancies. Whilst direct evidence linking screening with this fall in prevalence is lacking, it is likely that implementation of routine CL screening played an important role in the reduction of PTB rate. Our experience indicates that screening can be incorporated into the second-trimester anomaly scan. © 2022 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
比较以色列在发布推荐在孕中期进行超声宫颈长度(CL)测量的国家指南前后早产(PTB)(分娩前 37 周)的发生率。
以色列妇产科医师协会(ISOG)指南于 2012 年 1 月 1 日发布,规定 CL 应在 19-25 周的超声异常扫描时经腹部或经阴道进行测量,如果经腹部或经阴道测量不可行,则应进行测量,并且 CL < 25mm 应提示进一步检查和治疗,尽管未指定治疗类型。2000 年,以色列卫生部发布了一项法律要求,将分娩记录提交给国家登记处。这些数据用于比较指南发布前后(2000-2011 年和 2012-2020 年)PTB 的发生率,以及每个时间段内的趋势。信息可用于单胎和多胎妊娠以及母亲年龄和产次,还有低出生体重(< 2500g)。
在 2000-2020 年期间,以色列共有 3403976 名活产婴儿:在发布 ISOG 指南之前有 1797657 名,之后有 1606319 名。总体上有 247187 例 PTB,发生率为 7.64%(95%CI,7.52-7.77%),在发布指南之前为 7.64%,之后为 6.84%(95%CI,6.43-7.24%)(P<0.0002,双侧)。第一个时间段内的年度 PTB 发生率保持不变,但在指南发布后的第二个时间段内每年下降 0.18%。与指南发布前相比,指南发布后 PTB 发生率的比例降低了 10%,33-36 周的 PTB 发生率降低了 9%,28-32 周的 PTB 发生率降低了 18%,<28 周的 PTB 发生率降低了 24%。发布指南后,单胎妊娠的 PTB 发生率(5.49%之前 vs 4.83%之后,P<0.0001)有所降低,但双胞胎或以上多胎妊娠的婴儿没有降低。在发布指南后,无论是初产妇还是经产妇,19-39 岁的母亲年龄组,PTB 的发生率都有统计学显著降低。虽然在年龄较大的高危组(母亲年龄 < 19 岁和≥40 岁)也注意到了 PTB 发生率的降低,但未达到统计学意义。发布指南后,出生体重低于 2500g 的发生率也有统计学显著降低,其降低程度与 PTB 发生率相似。
在孕中期超声异常扫描时发布国家指南推荐常规 CL 测量,与单胎妊娠的 PTB 发生率下降相关。尽管缺乏将筛查与这种发病率下降直接联系起来的直接证据,但实施常规 CL 筛查很可能在降低 PTB 率方面发挥了重要作用。我们的经验表明,可以将筛查纳入孕中期超声异常扫描中。© 2022 年国际妇产科超声学会。