Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK.
Med Educ. 2023 Apr;57(4):315-330. doi: 10.1111/medu.14946. Epub 2022 Oct 23.
Impaired wellness among junior doctors is a significant problem. Connectedness and sense of belonging may be important factors to prevent and reduce mental ill-health. Shared social spaces in which health care staff can meet informally are thought to improve connectedness; however, these spaces are in decline. It is unclear what is known about such spaces, how they are used, and their impact on wellness and learning. This study aims to identify and synthetise available literature that informs our current understanding of the nature of shared social spaces as an intervention impacting wellness and learning of junior doctors.
A scoping review was conducted following the Arksey and O'Malley five-step framework. The review question is 'What is the evidence of the impact of shared social spaces on wellness and learning of junior doctors?' We searched five databases: MEDLINE, EMBASE, APA PsychINFO, APA PsychExtra, and ERIC. We conducted thorough supplementary searches in addition to the database search.
We included 41 articles. These were predominantly letters, commentaries, and editorials with only five primary research studies. We identified four significant common attributes of shared social spaces, which can be credited with positive impacts on wellness and learning: (1) Informal: fostering connectedness and belonging, trust and teamwork and offering access to informal help and support; (2) safe: allowing reflection, debrief and raising of concerns; (3) functional: there is planning of clinical care activity, sense of control and engagement from users and provision of refreshment; (4) legitimate: regular maintenance and use of shared social spaces affect role modelling, sustainability and wellness culture.
This review identified several ways in which shared social spaces impact positively on learning and wellness. There is little primary research in this area. Future research would be useful to further examine how and why this works.
初级医生的健康受损是一个严重的问题。联系感和归属感可能是预防和减少心理健康问题的重要因素。人们认为,医疗保健人员可以非正式会面的共享社交空间可以改善联系;然而,这些空间正在减少。目前尚不清楚这些空间的情况、它们的使用方式以及它们对健康和学习的影响。本研究旨在确定和综合现有文献,以了解共享社交空间作为影响初级医生健康和学习的干预措施的性质。
按照阿特赛和奥马利的五步框架进行了范围综述。综述问题是“关于共享社交空间对初级医生健康和学习的影响,有哪些证据?”我们搜索了五个数据库:MEDLINE、EMBASE、APA PsychINFO、APA PsychExtra 和 ERIC。除了数据库搜索外,我们还进行了彻底的补充搜索。
我们共纳入了 41 篇文章。这些文章主要是信件、评论和社论,只有 5 篇是原始研究。我们确定了共享社交空间的四个重要共同属性,这些属性可以对健康和学习产生积极影响:(1)非正式:促进联系感和归属感、信任和团队合作,并提供获取非正式帮助和支持的途径;(2)安全:允许反思、汇报和提出关切;(3)功能:规划临床护理活动、使用者有控制感和参与感并提供茶点;(4)合理:共享社交空间的定期维护和使用会影响角色模范、可持续性和健康文化。
本综述确定了共享社交空间对学习和健康产生积极影响的几种方式。该领域的原始研究较少。未来的研究将有助于进一步研究这种影响的方式和原因。