Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, USA.
Columbia University, New York, NY, USA.
Syst Rev. 2022 Oct 13;11(1):219. doi: 10.1186/s13643-022-02085-1.
This scoping review aims to provide a broad overview of the research on the unassisted virtual physical exam performed over synchronous audio-video telemedicine to identify gaps in knowledge and guide future research.
Searches for studies on the unassisted virtual physical exam were conducted in 3 databases. We included primary research studies in English on the virtual physical exam conducted via patient-to-provider synchronous, audio-video telemedicine in the absence of assistive technology or personnel. Screening and data extraction were performed by 2 independent reviewers.
Seventy-four studies met inclusion criteria. The most common components of the physical exam performed over telemedicine were neurologic (38/74, 51%), musculoskeletal (10/74, 14%), multi-system (6/74, 8%), neuropsychologic (5/74, 7%), and skin (5/74, 7%). The majority of the literature focuses on the telemedicine physical exam in the adult population, with only 5% of studies conducted specifically in a pediatric population. During the telemedicine exam, the patients were most commonly located in outpatient offices (28/74, 38%) and homes and other non-clinical settings (25/74, 34%). Both patients and providers in the included studies most frequently used computers for the telemedicine encounter.
Research evaluating the unassisted virtual physical exam is at an early stage of maturity and is skewed toward the neurologic, musculoskeletal, neuropsychologic, and skin exam components. Future research should focus on expanding the range of telemedicine exam maneuvers studied and evaluating the exam in the most relevant settings, which for telemedicine is trending toward exams conducted through mobile devices and in patients' homes.
本范围综述旨在提供一个广泛的概述,对通过同步音视频远程医疗进行的无辅助虚拟体检的研究,以确定知识差距并指导未来的研究。
在 3 个数据库中搜索关于无辅助虚拟体检的研究。我们纳入了英语的原始研究,研究对象是通过患者到提供者的同步、音视频远程医疗进行的虚拟体检,且无辅助技术或人员参与。由 2 名独立审查员进行筛选和数据提取。
74 项研究符合纳入标准。通过远程医疗进行的体检最常见的检查项目包括神经系统(38/74,51%)、肌肉骨骼系统(10/74,14%)、多系统(6/74,8%)、神经心理学(5/74,7%)和皮肤(5/74,7%)。大多数文献都集中在成人人群的远程医疗体检上,只有 5%的研究专门针对儿科人群。在远程医疗检查中,患者最常位于门诊办公室(28/74,38%)和家庭等非临床环境(25/74,34%)。纳入研究中的患者和提供者最常使用计算机进行远程医疗就诊。
评估无辅助虚拟体检的研究仍处于早期成熟阶段,主要集中在神经系统、肌肉骨骼系统、神经心理学和皮肤检查方面。未来的研究应侧重于扩大远程医疗检查操作的研究范围,并在最相关的环境中评估检查,对于远程医疗,趋势是通过移动设备和在患者家中进行检查。