Kawanaka Ryoko, Sakuma Shoko, Kokubun Hiroshi, Tetsu Shuhei, Tagaito Yugo, Igarashi Toshio, Liang Shan-Guang, Aoe Tomohiko
Department of Anesthesiology, Teikyo University Chiba Medical Center, Teikyo University, 3426-3 Anesaki, Ichihara City 299-0111, Chiba, Japan.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Teikyo University Chiba Medical Center, Teikyo University, 3426-3 Anesaki, Ichihara City 299-0111, Chiba, Japan.
J Clin Med. 2022 Sep 23;11(19):5587. doi: 10.3390/jcm11195587.
Fentanyl and short-acting remifentanil are often used in combination. We evaluated the effect of intraoperative opioid administration on postoperative pain and pain thresholds when the two drugs were used. Patients who underwent gynecological laparoscopic surgery were randomly assigned into two groups (15 patients each) to receive either sufficient (group A) or minimum (group B) fentanyl (maximum estimated effect site concentration: A: 7.86 ng/mL, B: 1.5 ng/mL). The estimated effect site concentration at the end of surgery was adjusted to the same level (1 ng/mL). Patients in both groups also received continuous intravenous remifentanil during surgery. The primary outcome was the pressure pain threshold, as evaluated by a pressure algometer 3 h postoperatively. The pressure pain threshold at 3 h postoperatively was 51.1% (95% CI: [44.4-57.8]) in group A and 56.6% [49.5-63.6] in group B, assuming a preoperative value of 100% ( = 0.298). There were no significant differences in pressure pain threshold and numeric rating scale scores between the groups after surgery. The pain threshold decreased significantly in both groups at 3 h postoperatively compared to preoperative values, and recovered at 24 h. Co-administration of both opioids caused hyperalgesia regardless of fentanyl dose.
芬太尼和短效瑞芬太尼常联合使用。我们评估了术中使用这两种药物时阿片类药物给药对术后疼痛和疼痛阈值的影响。接受妇科腹腔镜手术的患者被随机分为两组(每组15例),分别接受足量(A组)或最小量(B组)的芬太尼(最大估计效应室浓度:A组:7.86 ng/mL,B组:1.5 ng/mL)。手术结束时将估计的效应室浓度调整至相同水平(1 ng/mL)。两组患者在手术期间也均接受持续静脉输注瑞芬太尼。主要结局指标为术后3小时用压力痛觉计评估的压力疼痛阈值。假设术前值为100%,术后3小时A组的压力疼痛阈值为51.1%(95%CI:[44.4 - 57.8]),B组为56.6%[49.5 - 63.6](P = 0.298)。术后两组间压力疼痛阈值和数字评分量表得分无显著差异。与术前值相比,两组术后3小时疼痛阈值均显著降低,并在24小时时恢复。无论芬太尼剂量如何,两种阿片类药物联合使用均会导致痛觉过敏。