Kortlever Joost T P, Dekker Anne-Britt, Ring David, Vagner Gregg A, Reichel Lee M, Schuurman Arnold H, Coert J Henk
Department of Surgery and Perioperative Care, Dell Medical School-The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, United States.
Department of Plastic Surgery and Hand Surgery, University Medical Center Utrecht-Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
J Hand Microsurg. 2020 Oct 29;14(2):170-176. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1718968. eCollection 2022 Apr.
The benefit of radiographs or steroid injection for idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) or ulnar neuropathy at the elbow (UNE) is open to debate. We assessed: (1) Radiographs ordered and injections performed at a new patient visit for patients presenting with either idiopathic CTS or UNE; (2) The estimated payment reduction if we omit these interventions; and (3) Patient age, sex, geographic region, and work status associated with radiographs or injections at a new patient visit for patients presenting with either idiopathic CTS or UNE. Using a large database of commercial insurance claims, we identified patients with a new visit for either CTS ( = 9,522), UNE ( = 2,507), or both ( = 962; 8.7%). We identified injections and radiographs, and estimated total payments for these interventions. We created three multivariable logistic regression models for each diagnosis to identify factors associated with the interventions. Nearly one third of patients had radiographs at a new patient visit (30% and 32% for idiopathic CTS and UNE, respectively). Nearly 10% of patients with CTS and 2.6% with UNE received an injection. Both radiographs and injections representing annual minimum payments of over $345,000 and $294,000, respectively. Among people with CTS, radiographs were independently more common in the South and less common in the West. Injection for CTS was associated with younger age; North, Central, and South regions; and retired employment status. For people with UNE, radiographs were independently associated with younger age; South or West region; and retired or working employment status. Injection for UNE was associated with retired employment status. The prevalence of radiographs and injections suggests opportunities for savings, which might benefit clinicians with bundled or capitated payments and patients with large copayments or deductibles. The observed variation may reflect debate about whether these interventions are worthwhile. Diagnostic; Retrospective Database Level III study.
对于特发性腕管综合征(CTS)或肘管综合征(UNE),X线片或类固醇注射的益处尚无定论。我们评估了:(1)因特发性CTS或UNE就诊的新患者所开具的X线片及进行的注射治疗;(2)若省略这些干预措施估计可减少的费用;(3)因特发性CTS或UNE就诊的新患者中,与X线片或注射治疗相关的患者年龄、性别、地理区域及工作状态。利用一个大型商业保险理赔数据库,我们识别出因CTS(n = 9522)、UNE(n = 2507)或两者皆有(n = 962;8.7%)而进行初次就诊的患者。我们识别出注射治疗和X线片检查,并估算了这些干预措施的总费用。针对每种诊断情况,我们创建了三个多变量逻辑回归模型,以识别与这些干预措施相关的因素。近三分之一的患者在初次就诊时进行了X线片检查(特发性CTS和UNE患者分别为30%和32%)。近10%的CTS患者和2.6%的UNE患者接受了注射治疗。X线片检查和注射治疗每年的最低费用分别超过345,000美元和294,000美元。在CTS患者中,X线片检查在南部地区更为常见,而在西部地区较少见。CTS的注射治疗与较年轻的年龄、北部、中部和南部地区以及退休工作状态相关。对于UNE患者,X线片检查与较年轻的年龄、南部或西部地区以及退休或在职工作状态独立相关。UNE的注射治疗与退休工作状态相关。X线片检查和注射治疗的普遍性表明存在节省费用的机会,这可能使采用捆绑式或按人头付费的临床医生以及自付费用或免赔额较高的患者受益。观察到的差异可能反映了关于这些干预措施是否值得的争议。诊断性;回顾性数据库III级研究。