Department of Medical Sciences, Section of Dermatology, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
Ophthalmology Unit, A.O.U. City of Health and Science of Turin, Department of Surgical Sciences, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
Cutan Ocul Toxicol. 2022 Dec;41(4):318-322. doi: 10.1080/15569527.2022.2137177. Epub 2022 Oct 28.
Systemic retinoids are among the most prescribed drugs in dermatology, thanks to their activity as proliferation modulators and keratinisation normalisers. Common side effects such as blood lipid disorders, xerosis and photosensitivity are well established and usually dose dependent. Conversely, retinoid-associated ocular disturbances have been reported, yet with differences in terms of frequency and manifestations As data regarding a potential correlation with refractive errors are heterogenous and have not been previously thoroughly addressed, we performed a systematic review of the literature with the aim of comprehensively evaluating the current evidence regarding retinoid-associated myopia in dermatologic patients.
A systematic review of the literature was carried out according to the PRISMA guidelines. A search on MEDLINE, Pubmed, Scopus, Cochrane Library was conducted using the MeSH terms: retinoid, isotretinoin, acitretin, bexarotene, etretinate, alitretinoin, myopia, refractive errors, via the Boolean term AND. Only manuscripts in English were considered, there was no restriction on type of article. Animal research and in vitro studies were excluded.
Six articles were finally included in this systematic review. One well designed prospective study was able to show a slight myopic shift in the first six months, but id did not evaluate further development of the refractive error nor the effects of drug discontinuation. Another prospective study, with a smaller sample size showed no myopic progression at 12 months. Two case reports showed a myopic shift after two weeks from therapy start. Another case report showed a myopic shift associated with narrowing of the anterior chamber after one week from therapy start. Finally a large retrospective study based on spontaneous reporting systems and world's literature classified myopia as a certain side effect.
Considering the current literature, it is not possible to define a clear correlation between the use of retinoids and the development or worsening of myopia. Some studies suggest that retinoids may cause a myopic shift and the pathophysiologyical mechanism is supported by some animal and in vitro studies, but there is a lack of large prospective and well-controlled studies. In case of ocular disturbances after retinoid use a prompt ophthalmological referral is advisable and in case of the detection of a myopic refractive error a relationship to retinoids should be ruled out, considering also other possible causes such as age and previous refractive status.
由于具有增殖调节剂和角质正常化作用,全身性维甲酸类药物是皮肤科最常开的药物之一。常见的副作用,如血脂紊乱、干燥和光敏感性,已得到充分证实,通常与剂量有关。相反,已报道了与维甲酸相关的眼部疾病,但在频率和表现上存在差异。由于关于与屈光不正相关的潜在相关性的数据存在差异,且以前没有得到彻底解决,因此我们进行了系统的文献回顾,旨在全面评估皮肤科患者中与维甲酸相关近视的现有证据。
根据 PRISMA 指南进行了系统的文献回顾。使用 MeSH 术语在 MEDLINE、Pubmed、Scopus、Cochrane Library 上进行了检索:维甲酸、异维 A 酸、阿维 A 酯、贝沙罗汀、依曲替酯、阿利维 A 酸、近视、屈光不正,通过布尔术语 AND。仅考虑英文手稿,对文章类型没有限制。排除动物研究和体外研究。
最终纳入了 6 篇系统综述文章。一项精心设计的前瞻性研究能够在头 6 个月显示出轻微的近视漂移,但没有评估屈光不正的进一步发展或药物停用的影响。另一项前瞻性研究,样本量较小,在 12 个月时没有显示近视进展。两份病例报告显示,治疗开始后两周出现近视漂移。另一份病例报告显示,治疗开始后一周,前房变窄与近视有关。最后,一项基于自发报告系统和世界文献的大型回顾性研究将近视归类为一种确定的副作用。
考虑到目前的文献,不能明确界定维甲酸的使用与近视的发展或恶化之间的关系。一些研究表明,维甲酸可能会导致近视漂移,并且一些动物和体外研究支持其病理生理学机制,但缺乏大型前瞻性和对照良好的研究。如果在使用维甲酸后出现眼部疾病,应立即转介眼科治疗,如果发现近视性屈光不正,应排除与维甲酸的关系,同时还应考虑其他可能的原因,如年龄和以前的屈光状态。