Fomina D S, Mukhina O A, Lebedkina M S, Gadzhieva M K, Bobrikova E N, Sinyavkin D O, Parshin V V, Chernov A A, Belevskiy A S
City Clinic Hospital №52.
Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University (Sechenov University).
Ter Arkh. 2022 Mar 15;94(3):413-419. doi: 10.26442/00403660.2022.03.201437.
Guidelines on Biological Therapy for Bronchial Asthma of the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (EAACI) identified a number of controversial issues for additional outcome analysis using randomized clinical trials and data from routine clinical practice. In particular, there is unmet need to clarify algorithms for prescribing biologicals using predictors of response and its timing, taking into account risk factors and multimorbidity. Omalizumab is a recombinant humanized monoclonal anti-IgE antibody of IgG1 class used for the treatment of severe refractory atopic bronchial asthma (BA) and a variety of IgE-mediated diseases. Among biological agents, this "pioneer molecule" has the greatest experience in the "allergology and immunology" profile. Detailed description of the "nonresponders" portraits will allow to perform the therapy response assessment on time and facilitate rational planning of individual therapy, which is a prerequisite for biologicals era. Using only routine methods, it is possible to perform initial and dynamic screening to phenotype a heterogeneous cohort of patients with severe asthma and chose the optimal strategy.
To identify predictors of nonresponse to omalizumab anti-IgE therapy in patients with severe atopic BA and to establish optimal timing of efficacy assessment using retrospective analysis of data from the Biologic Therapy Registry of Allergology and Immunology in routine clinical practice.
A retrospective single-center registry study was conducted at the Allergy and Immunology Reference Center from June 2017 to August 2021. 135 patients with severe BA, with confirmed perennial sensitization, who received omalizumab according to the recommendations of the current version of GINA, were selected from the clinical and dynamic observational system (registry). Dosing regimen and administration frequency of omalizumab were determined in accordance with the instructions for the drug. Assessment of therapy efficacy was performed at the time point 4, 6 and 12 months. Patients were subgrouped into "responders" and "non-responders" according to the following criteria: ACT score less than 19 and/or difference between initial ACT score in dynamics less than 3 points; forced expiratory volume in the first second less than 80%; combination of these two criteria. Nonparametric methods of descriptive statistics were used in data processing: median, interquartile range. Differences were considered significant at p0.05. MannWhitney U-test, KruskalWallis one-way analysis of variance, and Fisher's 2 test were used to compare quantitative characteristics.
Heterogeneous subgroups of patients differing in reaching the criteria of "non-responders" to treatment were identified; the informativity of modifiable and unmodifiable factors differed at time-points of dynamic observation. In the differential analysis, two profiles of "nonresponders" were defined in combination with the most significant predictors of "nonrsponse" to omalizumab. According to the data obtained, one of the clinical phenotypes, namely the combination of severe asthma with the Samters triad, corresponded to the characteristics of the patient "nonresponders": age of onset is about 30 years, females, severe exacerbations of BA while taking non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, accompanied with high levels of eosinophilia.
The data obtained illustrates the hypothesis of pathogenetic heterogeneity of severe BA with the phenomenon of overlapping phenotypes and can serve as an additional orienteer for creating the individual plan of anti-IgE therapy in real clinical practice.
欧洲变态反应和临床免疫学会(EAACI)关于支气管哮喘生物治疗的指南确定了一些有争议的问题,需要通过随机临床试验和常规临床实践数据进行额外的结果分析。特别是,在考虑风险因素和多重疾病的情况下,仍有未满足的需求来阐明使用反应预测指标及其时机来开具生物制剂的算法。奥马珠单抗是一种IgG1类重组人源化单克隆抗IgE抗体,用于治疗重度难治性特应性支气管哮喘(BA)和多种IgE介导的疾病。在生物制剂中,这种“先驱分子”在“变态反应学和免疫学”领域拥有最丰富的经验。详细描述“无反应者”的特征将有助于及时进行治疗反应评估,并促进个体治疗的合理规划,这是生物制剂时代的先决条件。仅使用常规方法,就可以对重度哮喘患者的异质性队列进行初始和动态筛查,并选择最佳策略。
通过对常规临床实践中变态反应学和免疫学生物治疗登记处的数据进行回顾性分析,确定重度特应性BA患者对奥马珠单抗抗IgE治疗无反应的预测指标,并确定疗效评估的最佳时机。
2017年6月至2021年8月在变态反应和免疫学参考中心进行了一项回顾性单中心登记研究。从临床和动态观察系统(登记处)中选取135例确诊为常年致敏的重度BA患者,他们根据当前版本的GINA建议接受了奥马珠单抗治疗。奥马珠单抗的给药方案和给药频率根据药物说明书确定。在第4、6和12个月的时间点进行治疗疗效评估。根据以下标准将患者分为“反应者”和“无反应者”:ACT评分低于19分和/或动态初始ACT评分差异小于3分;第一秒用力呼气量低于80%;这两个标准的组合。数据处理采用非参数描述性统计方法:中位数、四分位间距。p<0.05时差异被认为具有统计学意义。采用Mann-Whitney U检验、Kruskal-Wallis单向方差分析和Fisher's 2检验比较定量特征。
确定了在达到治疗“无反应者”标准方面存在差异的患者异质性亚组;在动态观察的时间点,可改变和不可改变因素的信息性有所不同。在差异分析中,结合对奥马珠单抗“无反应”的最显著预测指标,定义了两种“无反应者”特征。根据获得的数据,其中一种临床表型,即重度哮喘与桑特斯三联征的组合,符合患者“无反应者”的特征:发病年龄约30岁,女性,服用非甾体抗炎药时BA重度加重,伴有高水平嗜酸性粒细胞增多。
获得的数据说明了重度BA发病机制异质性及表型重叠现象的假设,并可作为在实际临床实践中制定抗IgE治疗个体方案的额外指导。