Schmitt Harrison J, Black Adeena L, Keefer Lucas A, Sullivan Daniel
Department of Psychology, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona, USA.
School of Psychology, University of Southern Mississippi, Hattiesburg, Mississippi, USA.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2023 Jan;62 Suppl 1:111-135. doi: 10.1111/bjso.12592. Epub 2022 Oct 26.
Psychological research has shown that lower socioeconomic status (SES) individuals experience higher levels of stress and tend to cope in more present-oriented ways. While some research in the field has sought to, for instance, increase future-oriented ways of being among lower SES individuals, we argue that such approaches may come at significant cost. We consider the construct of time-space distanciation (TSD) - the normative way in which time and space are abstracted from one another at cultural and individual levels - as a way to complicate psychological research on social class, stress, and coping. Across four studies, we present research on US geographical regions (Studies 1-2) and US participants (Studies 3-4) suggesting that adopting normative high-TSD orientations represents a double-bind for lower SES individuals: it allows one to enact more proactive coping strategies in the face of financial stressors such as debt (Studies 1-3), but it is also a source of disproportionate stress itself (Study 4), given the burdens faced by lower SES individuals trying to navigate time and space in culturally hegemonic ways in spite of precarity and material insecurity. We discuss how TSD offers a means of situating psychological research into precarity within the broader structural context of flexible capitalism.
心理学研究表明,社会经济地位较低的个体承受着更高水平的压力,并且倾向于以更注重当下的方式应对。虽然该领域的一些研究试图,例如,在社会经济地位较低的个体中增加面向未来的生活方式,但我们认为这种方法可能会付出巨大代价。我们将时空疏离(TSD)这一概念——即在文化和个体层面上时间和空间相互抽象的规范方式——视为一种使关于社会阶层、压力和应对的心理学研究变得复杂的方式。在四项研究中,我们展示了关于美国地理区域(研究1 - 2)和美国参与者(研究3 - 4)的研究,表明采用规范的高TSD取向对社会经济地位较低的个体来说是一种两难境地:面对诸如债务等经济压力源时,它能让人采取更积极主动的应对策略(研究1 - 3),但鉴于社会经济地位较低的个体尽管面临不稳定和物质匮乏,仍试图以文化霸权方式驾驭时间和空间所承受的负担,它本身也是不成比例压力的一个来源(研究4)。我们讨论了TSD如何为将关于不稳定状态的心理学研究置于灵活资本主义的更广泛结构背景中提供一种方法。