Department of Stomatology, Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, Brazil.
Int J Dent Hyg. 2024 Aug;22(3):485-493. doi: 10.1111/idh.12641. Epub 2022 Nov 2.
Determine if different technology-based health education interventions can reduce oral health inequalities between the sexes in a sample of adolescents.
A cluster randomized clinical trial was conducted in three phases with an initial sample of 291 male and female adolescents 14-19 years of age. Phase I (n = 288) comprised a clinical examination performed by a calibrated examiner using the simplified oral hygiene index (OHI-S) and gingival bleeding index (GBI). Phase II involved two educational interventions: video (VD; n = 147) or oral counselling (OR; n = 141) with standardized content. In phase III, an App was made available to half of the clusters (OR + App; n = 66/OR without App; n = 71/VD + App; n = 63/VD without App; n = 63), and the clinical examination was performed a second time. Data were evaluated using descriptive analysis and nonparametric tests.
In phase I, boys had a lower standard of oral hygiene compared with girls, with higher mean OHI-S (p = 0.039) and GBI (p = 0.015). After VD and OR interventions, no significant difference between sexes was found regarding the mean OHI-S. However, males had a higher mean GBI compared with females in the OR group (p = 0.006). When the App was added to OR and VD groups, males in the 'OR without App' group had a higher mean GBI compared with females (p = 0.007).
This clinical trial demonstrated that educational interventions involving information technologies were effective at reducing oral health inequalities between the sexes among adolescents. However, oral counselling alone was not efficient in reducing GBI in male adolescents.
在青少年样本中,确定不同基于技术的健康教育干预措施是否可以减少性别之间的口腔健康不平等。
采用三阶段的整群随机临床试验,对初始样本为 14-19 岁的 291 名男性和女性青少年进行研究。第一阶段(n=288)包括由经过校准的检查者使用简化口腔卫生指数(OHI-S)和牙龈出血指数(GBI)进行临床检查。第二阶段包括两个教育干预措施:视频(VD;n=147)或口腔咨询(OR;n=141),内容标准化。在第三阶段,向一半的群组提供了一个应用程序(OR+App;n=66/OR 无应用程序;n=71/VD+App;n=63/VD 无应用程序;n=63),并进行了第二次临床检查。使用描述性分析和非参数检验评估数据。
在第一阶段,男孩的口腔卫生水平低于女孩,OHI-S(p=0.039)和 GBI(p=0.015)平均值较高。在 VD 和 OR 干预后,男女之间 OHI-S 的平均值没有差异。然而,在 OR 组中,男性的 GBI 平均值高于女性(p=0.006)。当 App 添加到 OR 和 VD 组中时,“OR 无应用程序”组中的男性 GBI 平均值高于女性(p=0.007)。
本临床试验表明,涉及信息技术的教育干预措施可有效减少青少年性别之间的口腔健康不平等。然而,单独的口腔咨询在降低男性青少年 GBI 方面效果不佳。